Burnet N G, Nyman J, Turesson I, Wurm R, Yarnold J R, Peacock J H
Radiotherapy Research Unit, Institute of Cancer Research, Sutton, Surrey UK.
Radiother Oncol. 1994 Dec;33(3):228-38. doi: 10.1016/0167-8140(94)90358-1.
There is a wide variation in normal tissue reactions to radiotherapy and in many situations the severity of these reactions limits radiotherapy dose. Clinical fractionation studies carried out in Gothenburg have demonstrated that a large part of the spectrum of normal tissue reactions is due to differences in individual normal tissue sensitivity. If this variation in normal tissue reactions is due to differences in intrinsic cellular radiosensitivity, it should be possible to predict tissue response based on measurement of cellular sensitivity. Here we report the initial results of a study aimed at establishing whether a direct relationship exists between cellular radiosensitivity and tissue response. Ten fibroblasts strains, including four duplicates, were established from a group of patients in the Gothenburg fractionation trials who had received radiotherapy following mastectomy. Skin doses were measured and both acute and late skin changes were observed following radiotherapy. Right and left parasternal areas were treated with different dose fractionation schedules. Clonogenic assays were used to assess intrinsic cellular radiosensitivity, and all experiments were carried out without prior knowledge of the clinical response, or which strains were duplicates. Irradiation was carried out using 60Co gamma-rays at high dose-rate (HDR) of 1-2 Gy/min and low dose-rate (LDR) of 1 cGy/min. A spectrum of sensitivity was seen, with SF2 values of 0.17-0.28 at HDR and 0.25-0.34 at LDR, and values of D0.01 of 5.07-6.38 Gy at HDR and 6.43-8.12 Gy at LDR. Comparison of the in vitro results with the clinical normal tissue effects shows a correlation between cellular sensitivity and late tissue reactions, which is highly significant with p = 0.02. A correlation between cellular sensitivity and acute effects was noted in the left-sided parasternal fields, but not the right. This is thought to be coincidental, and without biological significance. Our results suggest that cellular sensitivity might form the basis for the development of an assay system capable of predicting late normal tissue effects to curative radiotherapy, which might allow dose escalation in some patients. Increased local control and cure, with unchanged or improved normal tissue complications, could result from such individualised radiotherapy prescriptions.
正常组织对放疗的反应存在很大差异,在许多情况下,这些反应的严重程度限制了放疗剂量。在哥德堡进行的临床分次放疗研究表明,正常组织反应谱的很大一部分是由于个体正常组织敏感性的差异。如果正常组织反应的这种差异是由于内在细胞放射敏感性的不同,那么应该能够基于细胞敏感性的测量来预测组织反应。在此,我们报告一项研究的初步结果,该研究旨在确定细胞放射敏感性与组织反应之间是否存在直接关系。从哥德堡分次放疗试验中的一组接受乳房切除术后放疗的患者中建立了10株成纤维细胞系,包括4对复制品。测量皮肤剂量,并观察放疗后的急性和晚期皮肤变化。左右胸骨旁区域采用不同的剂量分割方案进行治疗。采用克隆形成试验评估内在细胞放射敏感性,所有实验均在不了解临床反应或哪些细胞系是复制品的情况下进行。使用60Coγ射线以1 - 2 Gy/分钟的高剂量率(HDR)和1 cGy/分钟的低剂量率(LDR)进行照射。观察到了一系列敏感性,HDR时SF2值为0.17 - 0.28,LDR时为0.25 - 0.34,HDR时D0.01值为5.07 - 6.38 Gy,LDR时为6.43 - 8.12 Gy。将体外结果与临床正常组织效应进行比较,结果显示细胞敏感性与晚期组织反应之间存在相关性,p = 0.02,具有高度显著性。在左侧胸骨旁区域观察到细胞敏感性与急性效应之间存在相关性,但右侧未观察到。这被认为是偶然的,没有生物学意义。我们的结果表明,细胞敏感性可能构成一种检测系统发展的基础,该系统能够预测根治性放疗对正常组织的晚期效应,这可能使一些患者能够提高放疗剂量。这种个体化的放疗方案可能会提高局部控制率和治愈率,同时使正常组织并发症保持不变或得到改善。