Nindl B C, Mahar M T, Harman E A, Patton J F
Occupational Physiology Division, US Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine, Natick, MA 01760-5008, USA.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1995 Feb;27(2):235-41.
Little data exist for upper and lower body mechanical power capability of adolescent athletes. This study compared arm (A) and leg (L) anaerobic peak and mean power (PP and MP) of 20 male and 20 female adolescent athletes after normalization for body mass (BM), fat-free mass (FFM), and lean A and L cross-sectional area (CSA). Power outputs were assessed by the Wingate anaerobic test. FFM and CSA were estimated via anthropometry. No significant (P > 0.05) differences existed between the sexes in Tanner sexual maturity, chronological age, or overall training activity. Males had higher (P < 0.001) absolute PP (W) (L 694 vs 442; A 494 vs 309) and MP (L 548 vs 307; A 337 vs 214). Ratio normalization and ANCOVA were used to remove the influence of body size differences. Ratio normalization showed that males had greater leg PP/BM, MP/BM, MP/FFM, MP/CSA, as well as arm PP/BM and MP/BM, whereas all leg and arm PP and MP ANCOVA adjusted means for BM, FFM, and CSA, except arm MP adjusted for FFM, were significantly (P < 0.01) higher for males than females. We conclude that factors other than muscle mass, possibly qualitative in nature, are responsible for the sex difference in anaerobic performance of adolescent athletes.
关于青少年运动员上下肢机械功率能力的数据很少。本研究比较了20名男性和20名女性青少年运动员在根据体重(BM)、去脂体重(FFM)以及瘦的上肢和下肢横截面积(CSA)进行标准化之后的上肢(A)和下肢(L)无氧峰值功率和平均功率(PP和MP)。功率输出通过温盖特无氧测试进行评估。FFM和CSA通过人体测量学估算。在坦纳性成熟度、实际年龄或总体训练活动方面,两性之间不存在显著(P>0.05)差异。男性的绝对PP(W)(下肢694对442;上肢494对309)和MP(下肢548对307;上肢337对214) 更高(P<0.001)。采用比率标准化和协方差分析来消除身体大小差异的影响。比率标准化显示,男性的下肢PP/BM、MP/BM、MP/FFM、MP/CSA以及上肢PP/BM和MP/BM更大,而除了根据FFM调整的上肢MP之外,所有下肢和上肢PP以及经协方差分析调整的BM、FFM和CSA的MP均值,男性均显著(P<0.01)高于女性。我们得出结论,除肌肉质量外,可能本质上是质量方面的因素,是青少年运动员无氧运动表现性别差异的原因。