Riding R, Burton D, Rees G, Sharratt M
Assessment Research Unit, School of Education, University of Birmingham, UK.
Br J Educ Psychol. 1995 Mar;65 ( Pt 1):113-24. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8279.1995.tb01135.x.
Three hundred and eighty 12-year-old children were asked to rate the pupils in their class on seven personality characteristics (Humorous, Shy, Outgoing, Patient, Quiet, Lively, and Serious; part of the sample also rated two additional characteristics, Helpful and Sensible). They were also given the Cognitive Styles Analysis (CSA) (Riding, 1991a) which measures an individual's position on two fundamental cognitive style dimensions; Verbal-Imagery and Wholist-Analytic. A factor analysis indicated that the seven personality characteristics could be viewed as three variables; and these were labelled as Active, Modest and Responsible. Personality characteristic ratings varied significantly as a function of Verbal-Imagery Cognitive Style. Verbalisers were more Active than Imagers, the intermediate position of Bimodal were most Modest and the Imagers were more Responsible than the Verbalisers. There was also a significant gender difference with the girls being more Modest and Responsible and the boys more Active. For the subsample, the only significant effect that was observed related to gender with the girls being rated as more Helpful and more Sensible than the boys.
380名12岁的儿童被要求对班上同学的七种性格特征(幽默、害羞、外向、耐心、安静、活泼和严肃;部分样本还对另外两种特征——乐于助人、明智进行了评分)进行评价。他们还接受了认知风格分析(CSA)(赖丁,1991a),该分析测量个体在两个基本认知风格维度上的位置:言语-表象和整体-分析。因素分析表明,这七种性格特征可被视为三个变量;并分别被标记为活跃、谦虚和负责。性格特征评分因言语-表象认知风格的不同而有显著差异。言语型者比表象型者更活跃,双峰型者处于中间位置且最谦虚,表象型者比言语型者更负责。此外,性别差异也很显著,女孩更谦虚、更负责,男孩更活跃。对于子样本,观察到的唯一显著影响与性别有关,女孩被评为比男孩更乐于助人、更明智。