Greenberg B, Quinones M A, Koilpillai C, Limacher M, Shindler D, Benedict C, Shelton B
Division of Cardiology, Oregon Health Sciences University, Portland, USA.
Circulation. 1995 May 15;91(10):2573-81. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.91.10.2573.
Studies of Left Ventricular Dysfunction (SOLVD) demonstrated that enalapril therapy significantly improved the clinical course of patients with left ventricular (LV) dysfunction. The goals of this substudy were to evaluate changes in LV structure and function in SOLVD patients and to test the hypothesis that enalapril inhibits remodeling in patients with LV dysfunction.
Patients entering both the prevention and treatment arms of SOLVD from 5 of the 23 clinical centers were recruited for this substudy. The 301 patients who participated underwent Doppler-echocardiographic evaluation according to standard protocol before randomization to either enalapril or placebo and again after 4 and 12 months of therapy. Recorded data were analyzed in a blinded fashion at a central core laboratory. Analysis of baseline clinical characteristics showed that patients enrolled in the substudy were generally representative of the SOLVD population, although prevention arm patients were slightly overrepresented in the substudy group (69.8% compared with 61.9% of remaining SOLVD patients). The enalapril group demonstrated significant reductions in the mitral annular E-wave-to-A-wave velocity ratio (due predominantly to a reduction in E-wave velocity), and this response was different from that seen in the placebo group (P = .030). Changes in the E-to-A ratio in the enalapril group correlated significantly with changes in plasma atrial natriuretic peptide (r = .56; P < or = .01). LV end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes increased in placebo but not enalapril-treated patients, and the differences in response between the treatment groups were significant (P = .025 and .019, respectively). LV mass tended to increase in placebo patients and to be reduced in enalapril-treated patients, and the difference in response between the groups was highly significant (P < or = .001).
These data demonstrate that enalapril attenuates progressive increases in LV dilatation and hypertrophy in patients with LV dysfunction. The results support the possibility that the favorable effects of enalapril reported in the SOLVD trials were related to inhibition of LV remodeling.
左心室功能障碍研究(SOLVD)表明,依那普利治疗可显著改善左心室(LV)功能障碍患者的临床病程。本亚组研究的目的是评估SOLVD患者左心室结构和功能的变化,并检验依那普利抑制LV功能障碍患者心脏重塑的假设。
从23个临床中心中的5个中心招募进入SOLVD预防和治疗组的患者参与本亚组研究。301名参与研究的患者在随机分组接受依那普利或安慰剂治疗前,按照标准方案进行多普勒超声心动图评估,并在治疗4个月和12个月后再次评估。记录的数据在中央核心实验室以盲法进行分析。基线临床特征分析表明,参与亚组研究的患者总体上代表了SOLVD人群,尽管预防组患者在亚组研究中占比略高(69.8%,而其余SOLVD患者为61.9%)。依那普利组二尖瓣环E波与A波速度比值显著降低(主要由于E波速度降低),且该反应与安慰剂组不同(P = 0.030)。依那普利组E/A比值的变化与血浆心钠素的变化显著相关(r = 0.56;P≤0.01)。安慰剂治疗的患者左心室舒张末期和收缩末期容积增加,而依那普利治疗的患者未增加,治疗组之间的反应差异显著(分别为P = 0.025和0.019)。安慰剂组患者左心室质量有增加趋势,而依那普利治疗组患者左心室质量减少,两组之间的反应差异非常显著(P≤0.001)。
这些数据表明,依那普利可减轻LV功能障碍患者左心室扩张和肥厚的进行性增加。结果支持SOLVD试验中报道的依那普利的有益作用与抑制LV重塑有关的可能性。