McCarrell N S, Callanan M A
University of California, Santa Cruz, USA.
Child Dev. 1995 Apr;66(2):532-46. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.1995.tb00888.x.
Perceptual similarity among concept members has been viewed as inadequate to motivate concept formation. Instead, it has been argued that intuitive beliefs about the world offer more structured motivation for concepts. Our research explores children's beliefs about the relations between perceptually based similarity among things and their predicted behaviors. We focus on form-function correspondences as fundamental components of very young children's belief systems. Groups of 2- and 4-year-old children were asked to choose which of 2 line-drawn animals evidenced a particular "function," a special behavior. Even the youngest children showed sensitivity to form-function correspondences by selecting the animal whose form afforded the particular function. A second study investigated how form-function correspondences affect the relative influences of perceptual similarity and shared labels over patterns of children's inference. Perceptual similarity, if "motivated" by intuitive beliefs about correspondences between form and function, was found to be sufficient basis for inference and a more robust basis than shared labels when children attributed meaningful functions to novel animal forms.
概念成员之间的感知相似性被认为不足以激发概念形成。相反,有人认为,关于世界的直观信念为概念提供了更具结构性的动机。我们的研究探讨了儿童对于事物之间基于感知的相似性与其预测行为之间关系的信念。我们将形式-功能对应关系视为幼儿信念系统的基本组成部分。我们让2岁和4岁的儿童组选择两只线条画动物中哪一只表现出一种特定的“功能”,即一种特殊行为。即使是最小的儿童也通过选择其形态能够实现特定功能的动物,表现出对形式-功能对应关系的敏感性。第二项研究调查了形式-功能对应关系如何影响感知相似性和共享标签对儿童推理模式的相对影响。当儿童将有意义的功能赋予新颖的动物形态时,如果感知相似性受到关于形式与功能对应关系的直观信念的“驱动”,那么它被发现是推理的充分基础,并且比共享标签更可靠。