Materson B J, Reda D J, Cushman W C
Cooperative Studies Program of the Medical Research Service, Department of Veterans Affairs, Miami, Florida, USA.
Am J Hypertens. 1995 Feb;8(2):189-92. doi: 10.1016/0895-7061(94)00196-i.
The antihypertensive efficacy of six drugs and placebo was compared in 1292 men with untreated diastolic blood pressure of 95 to 109 mm Hg. The primary end point "success" was defined as the patient having achieved a diastolic blood pressure of < 90 mm Hg at the end of the drug titration period and having maintained a diastolic blood pressure of < 95 mm Hg for 1 year without drug intolerance. The original published success rate data (N Engl J Med 1993;328:914-921) were discovered to be in error due to a computer programming code omission (N Engl J Med 1994;330:1689). This paper presents corrected graphic figures. The corrected success rates were generally higher than originally published. Overall, diltiazem (72%) was significantly higher than hydrochlorothiazide (55%), prazosin (54%), captopril (50%), and placebo (31%); clonidine (62%) and atenolol (60%) were intermediate. There were some changes in the hierarchy of drug response, but important differences in success rates according to age by race subgroups remained. Whites responded well to all drug classes, except for lower efficacy of hydrochlorothiazide in younger whites. Blacks responded better to diltiazem than other agents. In addition, we have analyzed the data using a definition of success based on < 90 mm Hg for 1 year. Use of the <90 mm Hg criterion reduced the rate of success, but had only a minor effect on the drug success rate hierarchy. We conclude that single-drug antihypertensive therapy is effective in a majority of stage 1 to 2 diastolic hypertensive patients, although there are important age-by-race differences in success rates among various drug classes.
在1292名未经治疗、舒张压为95至109毫米汞柱的男性中,比较了六种药物和安慰剂的降压效果。主要终点“成功”定义为患者在药物滴定期结束时舒张压降至<90毫米汞柱,并在无药物不耐受的情况下将舒张压维持在<95毫米汞柱达1年。由于计算机编程代码遗漏,发现最初发表的成功率数据(《新英格兰医学杂志》1993年;328:914 - 921)有误(《新英格兰医学杂志》1994年;330:1689)。本文给出了校正后的图表。校正后的成功率普遍高于最初发表的结果。总体而言,地尔硫䓬(72%)显著高于氢氯噻嗪(55%)、哌唑嗪(54%)、卡托普利(50%)和安慰剂(31%);可乐定(62%)和阿替洛尔(60%)处于中间水平。药物反应的层次结构有一些变化,但按年龄和种族亚组划分的成功率仍存在重要差异。白人对所有药物类别反应良好,只是氢氯噻嗪在年轻白人中的疗效较低。黑人对地尔硫䓬的反应比其他药物更好。此外,我们使用基于舒张压<90毫米汞柱达1年的成功定义对数据进行了分析。采用<90毫米汞柱的标准降低了成功率,但对药物成功率的层次结构影响较小。我们得出结论,单药降压治疗对大多数1至2期舒张期高血压患者有效,尽管不同药物类别之间按年龄和种族划分的成功率存在重要差异。