McEwen J E, Reilly P R
Eunice Kennedy Shriver Center for Mental Retardation, Division of Social Science, Ethics, and Law, Waltham, MA 02254, USA.
Am J Hum Genet. 1995 Jun;56(6):1477-86.
This article reports the findings of a survey of 148 academically based and commercial DNA diagnostic labs regarding DNA banking (defined as the storage of individual DNA samples in some form with identifiers for later retrieval). The population surveyed consisted of all laboratories listed with HELIX, a national directory of DNA diagnostic labs that includes a fairly comprehensive listing of clinical service labs as well as a large number of research labs. The survey was concerned primarily with the legal and ethical issues that the long-term storage of DNA may raise. The survey inquired into the respondents' policies and procedures concerning (1) the extent of DNA banking and of interest in developing DNA banking in academia and industry and (2) the degree to which DNA banks had developed written internal policies and/or a written depositor's agreement (a signed document defining the rights and obligations of the person from whom the sample was taken and the bank) designed to anticipate or prevent some of the ethical and legal problems that can arise from the long-term retention of DNA. Our research suggests that (1) the activity of DNA banking is growing, particularly in the academic setting, and (2) most academically based DNA banks lack written internal policies, written depositor's agreements, or other relevant documentation regarding important aspects of this activity.
本文报告了一项针对148家学术型和商业性DNA诊断实验室的DNA库(定义为以某种形式存储个体DNA样本并带有标识符以便日后检索)的调查结果。被调查人群包括所有列入HELIX的实验室,HELIX是一份DNA诊断实验室的全国名录,其中包含临床服务实验室的相当全面的清单以及大量研究实验室。该调查主要关注DNA长期存储可能引发的法律和伦理问题。调查询问了受访者关于以下方面的政策和程序:(1)DNA库的规模以及学术界和工业界对发展DNA库的兴趣;(2)DNA库制定书面内部政策和/或书面储户协议(一份签署文件,定义样本提供者和DNA库的权利与义务)的程度,这些政策和协议旨在预见或防止长期保留DNA可能引发的一些伦理和法律问题。我们的研究表明:(1)DNA库活动正在增加,尤其是在学术环境中;(2)大多数学术型DNA库缺乏关于该活动重要方面的书面内部政策、书面储户协议或其他相关文件。