Carleton R A, Lasater T M, Assaf A R, Feldman H A, McKinlay S
Department of Medicine, Memorial Hospital of Rhode Island, Pawtucket 02860, USA.
Am J Public Health. 1995 Jun;85(6):777-85. doi: 10.2105/ajph.85.6.777.
Whether community-wide education changed cardiovascular risk factors and disease risk in Pawtucket, RI, relative to a comparison community was assessed.
Random-sample, cross-sectional surveys were done of people aged 18 through 64 years at baseline, during, and after education. Baseline cohorts were reexamined. Pawtucket citizens of all ages participated in multilevel education, screening, and counseling programs.
The downward trend in smoking was slightly greater in the comparison city. Small, insignificant differences favored Pawtucket in blood cholesterol and blood pressure. In the cross-sectional surveys, body mass index increased significantly in the comparison community; a similar change was not seen in cohort surveys. Projected cardiovascular disease rates were significantly (16%) less in Pawtucket during the education program. This difference lessened to 8% posteducation.
The hypothesis that projected cardiovascular disease risk can be altered by community-based education gains limited support from these data. Achieving cardiovascular risk reduction at the community level was feasible, but maintaining statistically significant differences between cities was not. Accelerating risk factor changes will likely require a sustained community effort with reinforcement from state, regional, and national policies and programs.
评估罗德岛州波塔基特市开展的社区范围教育相对于一个对照社区,是否改变了心血管危险因素和疾病风险。
在教育开展前、期间和之后,对18至64岁的人群进行随机抽样横断面调查。对基线队列进行重新检查。波塔基特市所有年龄段的居民都参与了多层次教育、筛查和咨询项目。
对照城市吸烟率的下降趋势略大。在血液胆固醇和血压方面,波塔基特市有微小的、不显著的优势。在横断面调查中,对照社区的体重指数显著增加;队列调查中未观察到类似变化。在教育项目期间,波塔基特市预计的心血管疾病发病率显著降低(16%)。教育结束后,这一差异降至8%。
基于社区的教育可以改变预计心血管疾病风险这一假设从这些数据中获得的支持有限。在社区层面实现心血管风险降低是可行的,但要保持城市之间具有统计学意义的差异则不可行。加速危险因素的改变可能需要社区持续努力,并得到州、地区和国家政策及项目的强化支持。