Krumholz A, Ness P M, Hauser W A, Douglas D K, Gibble J W
Department of Neurology, University of Maryland Medical Center, Baltimore, USA.
Transfusion. 1995 Jun;35(6):470-4. doi: 10.1046/j.1537-2995.1995.35695288764.x.
Individuals with epilepsy or seizure disorders are restricted from donating blood because of concern that they are prone to adverse donor reactions such as syncope and convulsions. A study evaluating whether that concern is warranted is reported.
During a 2-year period beginning in 1987, blood donors in Maryland with a history of seizures were actively recruited by the American Red Cross. Adverse donor reactions were classified as "slight", indicating dizziness and nausea without loss of consciousness; "moderate," denoting syncope; and "severe," indicating convulsive syncope.
There were 329,143 satisfactory blood donations; 613 individuals reporting a history of seizures donated blood a total of 723 times. Among donors with seizures, 186 (35.7%) were taking antiepileptic medication, and 61 (8.4%) had had one or more seizures in the preceding year. Individuals with seizures had a low incidence of adverse reactions (3.34%). Although this incidence was slightly higher than that in the entire population (2.24%), the difference was not significant. In particular, the risk of syncope with or without convulsive activity was low for people with seizures (0.21%) and not significantly greater than that in other donors (0.28%).
Individuals with seizures or epilepsy are not at greater risk for adverse reactions after blood donation, and major restrictions on their participation as blood donors are not warranted.
癫痫或发作性疾病患者被限制献血,因为担心他们容易出现诸如晕厥和抽搐等献血者不良反应。本文报道了一项评估这种担忧是否合理的研究。
从1987年开始的两年期间,美国红十字会积极招募有癫痫发作史的马里兰州献血者。献血者不良反应被分类为“轻微”,指头晕和恶心但未失去意识;“中度”,指晕厥;“严重”,指惊厥性晕厥。
共有329,143次满意的献血;613名有癫痫发作史的个体共献血723次。在有癫痫发作史的献血者中,186人(35.7%)正在服用抗癫痫药物,61人(8.4%)在前一年有过一次或多次癫痫发作。有癫痫发作史的个体不良反应发生率较低(3.34%)。虽然这一发生率略高于总体人群(2.24%),但差异不显著。特别是,有癫痫发作史的人出现伴有或不伴有惊厥活动的晕厥风险较低(0.21%),且不显著高于其他献血者(0.28%)。
有癫痫发作或癫痫的个体献血后出现不良反应的风险并不更高,对其作为献血者参与献血进行重大限制是没有必要的。