Myers D E, Myers R A
Department of Oral Medicine and Pathology, University of Pittsburgh School of Dental Medicine, PA 15261, USA.
Headache. 1995 Apr;35(4):197-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.1995.hed3504197.x.
Oxygen inhalation was early advocated as a treatment for migraine headache. It has been theorized that the efficacy of raising blood oxygen levels in vascular headache is mediated by vasoconstriction and metabolic effects. Hyperbaric oxygen can provide a much greater level of blood oxygenation than can provide a much greater level of blood oxygenation than normobaric oxygen, and in recent studies it has been used in the treatment of cluster headache. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of hyperbaric oxygen and normobaric oxygen in migraine. Twenty migraineurs were divided randomly into two groups and studied in a hyperbaric chamber during a typical headache attack. Global headache severity was measured by a verbal descriptor scale before and after exposure to oxygen. One group received 100% oxygen at 1 atmosphere of pressure (normobaric) while the other received 100% oxygen at 2 atmospheres of pressure (hyperbaric). One of the 10 patients in the normobaric group achieved significant relief of headache symptoms, while 9 of 10 in the hyperbaric group found relief. Based on a chi-square test, this difference is significant at the P < .005 level. Those patients who did not find significant relief from normobaric oxygen were given hyperbaric oxygen as above. All nine found significant relief. The results suggest that hyperbaric (but not normobaric) oxygen may be useful in the abortive management of migraine headache. Possibilities for the mechanism of this effect, in addition to vasoconstriction, include an increase in the rate of energy-producing and neurotransmitter-related metabolic reactions in the brain which require molecular oxygen.
吸氧疗法很早就被提倡用于治疗偏头痛。从理论上来说,在血管性头痛中提高血氧水平的疗效是通过血管收缩和代谢效应来介导的。高压氧能比常压氧提供更高水平的血液氧合作用,并且在最近的研究中,它已被用于治疗丛集性头痛。本研究的目的是比较高压氧和常压氧对偏头痛的治疗效果。20名偏头痛患者被随机分为两组,并在典型的头痛发作期间在高压氧舱中进行研究。在吸氧前后,通过言语描述量表来测量整体头痛的严重程度。一组在1个大气压下接受100%的氧气(常压),而另一组在2个大气压下接受100%的氧气(高压)。常压组的10名患者中有1名头痛症状得到显著缓解,而高压组的10名患者中有9名症状得到缓解。基于卡方检验,这种差异在P < 0.005水平上具有显著性。那些常压氧治疗后未获得显著缓解的患者,按上述方法给予高压氧治疗。所有9名患者均获得显著缓解。结果表明高压氧(而非常压氧)可能对偏头痛的发作性治疗有用。除血管收缩外,这种效应的机制还可能包括大脑中与能量产生和神经递质相关的代谢反应速率增加,这些反应需要分子氧。