Carty N J, Carter C, Rubin C, Ravichandran D, Royle G T, Taylor I
Breast Unit, Royal South Hants Hospital, Southampton.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1995 Mar;77(2):127-30.
Fibroadenoma is a common cause of discrete breast lumps in young women. There is agreement that fibroadenomas can be diagnosed preoperatively with a high degree of confidence and that some of the lesions thus diagnosed will resolve, possibly obviating the need for excision. There is, however, wide disagreement over the proportion of fibroadenomas that resolve spontaneously and therefore the benefit that accrues from an expectant policy. The aim of this study was to audit the management of fibroadenomas on one unit and clarify their natural history over a 5-year period. A cohort of 70 women with 87 fibroadenomas diagnosed using a triple assessment of clinical examination, cytology and imaging (sonomammography) have been followed for a minimum of 5 years. In all, 53 of the 'fibroadenomas' have been excised. In four cases the histology revealed benign disease other than fibroadenoma; there were no neoplasms. The sensitivity of cytology and sonomammography for the diagnosis of fibroadenoma were 84% and 98% respectively. Thirty-four fibroadenomas have not been excised. Of 25 fibroadenomas that have been reassessed after at least 5 years of follow-up, 13 (52%) have reduced in size, 4 (16%) are unchanged in size and 8 (32%) have grown. No patient has developed a carcinoma at the site of the presumed fibroadenoma. This study confirms that an expectant management policy of fibroadenomas has not resulted in misdiagnosis of carcinomas. Further, since a significant proportion of fibroadenomas remain static or reduce in size over a 5-year period many women can avoid excision.
纤维腺瘤是年轻女性乳腺出现离散性肿块的常见原因。人们一致认为,纤维腺瘤在术前能够被高度准确地诊断出来,而且一些经诊断的病灶会自行消退,这可能使切除手术不再必要。然而,对于能自行消退的纤维腺瘤的比例以及因此而采取的观察等待策略的益处,存在广泛的分歧。本研究的目的是审查某一科室对纤维腺瘤的处理情况,并阐明其在5年期间的自然病程。对一组70名患有87个纤维腺瘤的女性进行了研究,这些纤维腺瘤通过临床检查、细胞学检查和影像学检查(乳腺超声)的三联评估得以诊断,并对她们进行了至少5年的随访。总共有53个“纤维腺瘤”被切除。在4例病例中,组织学检查显示为除纤维腺瘤以外的良性疾病;没有发现肿瘤。细胞学检查和乳腺超声对纤维腺瘤诊断的敏感性分别为84%和98%。有34个纤维腺瘤未被切除。在对25个纤维腺瘤进行了至少5年的随访后重新评估发现,其中13个(52%)体积缩小,4个(16%)大小未变,8个(32%)体积增大。没有患者在疑似纤维腺瘤的部位发生癌变。这项研究证实,对纤维腺瘤采取观察等待的处理策略不会导致对癌症的误诊。此外,由于相当一部分纤维腺瘤在5年期间保持稳定或体积缩小,许多女性可以避免接受切除手术。