Daro D A
Future Child. 1994 Summer-Fall;4(2):198-223.
Efforts to prevent child sexual abuse have taken a distinctly different path from efforts to prevent the physical abuse of children. Currently, child sexual abuse prevention is virtually synonymous with group-based instruction for children on personal safety, and it appears that most schools and many after-school programs provide some form of group-based sexual abuse prevention education. Many evaluations have assessed the impact of these efforts. Seventeen studies employing random assignment to treatment and control groups are summarized in Table 1 on page 206, and 21 additional studies using quasi-experimental designs are briefly reviewed in the article text. Most studies conclude that children do learn from the experience, although such learning is neither universal nor comprehensive. Most evaluations measure the child's knowledge but are unable to assess whether a gain in knowledge will lead to a sustained beneficial change in the child's behavior. In an effort to focus on behavior change, child safety programs increasingly utilize role playing and participant modeling. A major benefit of personal safety education programs may be an increased rate of disclosures by children of past or present abuse. A major area of concern may be the potential for safety education programs to engender fear and anxiety in children Research on negative impacts is limited, and results have been mixed. The author concludes that prevention programs overall have beneficial impacts, which are strongest for children 7 to 12 years old. Characteristics of promising programs are summarized. The article concludes with suggestions for expanding prevention efforts to include public and parent education, life skills training for young adults, support groups for vulnerable children and adults, and intervention for identified victims and perpetrators.
预防儿童性虐待的努力与预防儿童身体虐待的努力走上了截然不同的道路。目前,预防儿童性虐待几乎等同于针对儿童开展的个人安全集体教育,而且似乎大多数学校和许多课外项目都提供某种形式的集体性虐待预防教育。许多评估都考察了这些努力的影响。第206页表1总结了17项采用随机分配治疗组和对照组的研究,本文还简要回顾了另外21项采用准实验设计的研究。大多数研究得出结论,儿童确实能从这种经历中学习,尽管这种学习既不普遍也不全面。大多数评估衡量的是儿童的知识,但无法评估知识的增加是否会导致儿童行为持续产生有益变化。为了专注于行为改变,儿童安全项目越来越多地采用角色扮演和参与者示范。个人安全教育项目的一个主要好处可能是儿童披露过去或现在遭受虐待情况的比例有所增加。一个主要的担忧领域可能是安全教育项目有可能在儿童中引发恐惧和焦虑。关于负面影响的研究有限,结果也喜忧参半。作者得出结论,总体而言预防项目有有益影响,对7至12岁的儿童影响最强。文中总结了有前景的项目的特点。文章最后提出了一些建议,以扩大预防工作的范围,包括公众教育和家长教育、为年轻人提供生活技能培训、为弱势儿童和成年人提供支持小组,以及对已确认的受害者和施虐者进行干预。