Martin D F, DeBarge L R, Nussenblatt R B, Chan C C, Roberge F G
Laboratory of Immunology, National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892.
J Immunol. 1995 Jan 15;154(2):922-7.
Immunosuppressive drugs currently available for the treatment of autoimmune diseases display a narrow therapeutic window between efficacy and toxic side effects. The use of combinations of drugs that have a synergistic effect may expand this window and reduce the risk of toxicity. We evaluated the combination effect of rapamycin (Rapa) and cyclosporin A (CsA) in an autoimmune disease model of the eye. The dose-effect relationship of Rapa with CsA was measured in vitro on the inhibition of proliferation of retinal S-Ag-primed lymphocytes. A median effect analysis was performed and a combination index (CI) calculated for 50% inhibition of proliferation. Rapa and CsA were markedly synergistic over a wide dose range (lowest CI = 0.31). Calculated dose reduction factors indicated that Rapa could be reduced nine-fold and CsA reduced five-fold when these drugs were used in combination. These reduced doses were tested in vivo for the treatment of experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis (EAU). Twelve of 15 rats treated with CsA, 2 mg/kg/day, developed EAU with a median severity of 2.5. Fourteen of 15 rats treated with Rapa, 0.01 mg/kg/day, developed EAU with a median severity of 3.25. Complete inhibition of EAU was achieved in all 15 animals treated with the combination of Rapa and CsA (combined vs CsA alone, p < 0.0002; combined vs Rapa alone, p < 0.00001). The demonstrated synergistic relationship between Rapa and CsA will allow the use of reduced doses of each drug to achieve a therapeutic effect. The use of lower doses may reduce the toxicity of these drugs for the treatment of autoimmune uveitis.
目前可用于治疗自身免疫性疾病的免疫抑制药物在疗效和毒副作用之间的治疗窗口较窄。使用具有协同作用的药物组合可能会扩大这个窗口并降低毒性风险。我们在眼部自身免疫性疾病模型中评估了雷帕霉素(Rapa)和环孢素A(CsA)的联合效果。在体外测量了Rapa与CsA对视网膜S抗原致敏淋巴细胞增殖抑制的剂量效应关系。进行了中位效应分析,并计算了50%增殖抑制的联合指数(CI)。Rapa和CsA在很宽的剂量范围内具有明显的协同作用(最低CI = 0.31)。计算出的剂量降低因子表明,当这两种药物联合使用时,Rapa的剂量可降低9倍,CsA的剂量可降低5倍。这些降低后的剂量在体内用于治疗实验性自身免疫性葡萄膜视网膜炎(EAU)。15只接受2 mg/kg/天CsA治疗的大鼠中有12只发生了EAU,中位严重程度为2.5。15只接受0.01 mg/kg/天Rapa治疗的大鼠中有14只发生了EAU,中位严重程度为3.25。用Rapa和CsA联合治疗的所有15只动物的EAU均得到完全抑制(联合治疗组与单独使用CsA组相比,p < 0.0002;联合治疗组与单独使用Rapa组相比,p < 0.00001)。Rapa和CsA之间已证明的协同关系将允许使用每种药物的降低剂量来达到治疗效果。使用较低剂量可能会降低这些药物治疗自身免疫性葡萄膜炎的毒性。