Vander Velpen G C, Shimi S M, Cuschieri A
Department of Surgery, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, University of Dundee.
Gut. 1994 Nov;35(11):1617-21. doi: 10.1136/gut.35.11.1617.
A prospective audit of the diagnostic yield and management benefit of laparoscopy was undertaken in 220 consecutive patients. The procedure was performed electively in 180 patients and as an emergency in 40. The indications for laparoscopy in the elective group were suspected hepatic disease, staging of intra-abdominal malignancy, diagnostic problems, and chronic abdominal pain. Emergency laparoscopy was performed in patients admitted with acute abdominal pain. Diagnostic benefit varied with the indication for the procedure: liver disease 71%, tumour staging 87%, uncertain diagnosis 74%, acute abdominal pain 100%, and chronic abdominal pain 41%. Clinical management was significantly influenced by laparoscopy in 15 of 21 (71%) patients with liver disease, 10 of 30 (33%) with intra-abdominal malignancy, 5 of 19 (26%) with uncertain diagnosis, 32 of 40 (80%) with acute abdominal pain, and 15 of 110 (23%) patients with chronic abdominal pain. A wrong assessment of the nature or stage of the disease was made by laparoscopy in 3 of 220 (1.0%). There was no morbidity or mortality attributed to laparoscopy in the study.
对连续220例患者进行了腹腔镜检查诊断率及管理效益的前瞻性审计。180例患者为择期进行该手术,40例为急诊手术。择期组腹腔镜检查的适应证为疑似肝脏疾病、腹内恶性肿瘤分期、诊断问题及慢性腹痛。急诊腹腔镜检查用于因急性腹痛入院的患者。诊断效益因手术适应证而异:肝脏疾病为71%,肿瘤分期为87%,诊断不确定为74%,急性腹痛为100%,慢性腹痛为41%。在21例(71%)肝脏疾病患者中,15例患者的临床管理受到腹腔镜检查的显著影响;30例腹内恶性肿瘤患者中,10例(33%)受影响;19例诊断不确定患者中,5例(26%)受影响;40例急性腹痛患者中,32例(80%)受影响;110例慢性腹痛患者中,15例(23%)受影响。220例患者中有3例(1.0%)因腹腔镜检查对疾病性质或分期评估错误。本研究中腹腔镜检查未导致任何发病率或死亡率。