O'Connor T C, Abram S E
Department of Anesthesiology, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee 53226.
Anesthesiology. 1995 Jan;82(1):259-66. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199501000-00031.
Subcutaneous injection of dilute formalin in the hind paw of the rat produces a biphasic nociceptive response. Initial C-fiber activity is accompanied by flinching of the paw for about 5 min (phase 1), followed by cessation of activity and resumption of flinching beginning 15 min after injection and lasting about 40 min or more (phase 2). The second phase depends on changes in dorsal horn cell function that occur shortly after the initial C-fiber discharge. It was previously shown that isoflurane, administered during phase 1, reduced phase 2 activity, but a combination of isoflurane and nitrous oxide given throughout phase 1 did not suppress spinal sensitization. The same model was used to determine the effects of several inhalation and intravenous anesthetic agents on phase 2 of the formalin test.
The formalin test was carried out on male Sprague-Dawley rats. Animals anesthetized briefly with halothane to facilitate formalin injection, were compared to animals that received 1 MAC anesthesia from 5 min before to 6 min after formalin injection using halothane, enflurane, isoflurane, desflurane, or 70% N2O, or a combination of nitrous oxide plus 1 MAC halothane. Animals that were given intravenous saline immediately before injection of formalin were compared to animals given either 20 mg/kg intravenous thiopental just before formalin injection or 10 mg/kg intravenous propofol just before and 3 mg/kg immediately after formalin injection. Flinches/minute were counted at 1 and 5 min after formalin injection and thereafter at 5-min intervals for 1 h. The total of 1- and 5-min flinches were considered phase 1 activity and the total of 10-60-min flinches were considered phase 2. Total phase 2 activity was compared between groups using one-way analysis of variance.
Animals that received halothane, enflurane, isoflurane, desflurane, or nitrous oxide during phase 1 demonstrated a significant decrease in phase 2 activity when compared to controls, while those that received a combination of nitrous oxide and halothane exhibited no difference. Animals that received intravenous thiopental anesthesia during phase 1 demonstrated no difference in phase 2 activity when compared to controls, whereas those that received propofol during phase 1 demonstrated a significant decrease of phase 2 activity.
Volatile anesthetics or nitrous oxide significantly suppress spinal sensitization, whereas the combination of nitrous oxide plus halothane causes no suppression. Thiopental does not affect spinal sensitization, whereas propofol causes significant suppression. These results may have important implications regarding the development of postoperative pain.
在大鼠后爪皮下注射稀释的福尔马林会产生双相伤害性反应。最初的C纤维活动伴随着爪子抽搐约5分钟(第1阶段),随后活动停止,注射后15分钟开始再次抽搐并持续约40分钟或更长时间(第2阶段)。第二阶段取决于最初C纤维放电后不久发生的背角细胞功能变化。先前的研究表明,在第1阶段给予异氟烷可降低第2阶段的活动,但在整个第1阶段给予异氟烷和氧化亚氮的组合并不能抑制脊髓敏化。使用相同的模型来确定几种吸入和静脉麻醉剂对福尔马林试验第2阶段的影响。
对雄性Sprague-Dawley大鼠进行福尔马林试验。将用氟烷短暂麻醉以方便注射福尔马林的动物,与在福尔马林注射前5分钟至注射后6分钟接受1个最低肺泡有效浓度(MAC)麻醉的动物进行比较,这些动物使用氟烷、恩氟烷、异氟烷、地氟烷或70%氧化亚氮,或氧化亚氮加1个MAC氟烷的组合。将在注射福尔马林前立即静脉注射生理盐水的动物,与在福尔马林注射前静脉注射20mg/kg硫喷妥钠或在福尔马林注射前立即静脉注射10mg/kg丙泊酚并在注射后立即静脉注射3mg/kg丙泊酚的动物进行比较。在福尔马林注射后1分钟和5分钟计数每分钟的抽搐次数,此后每隔5分钟计数1小时。将1分钟和5分钟的抽搐总数视为第1阶段活动,将10至60分钟的抽搐总数视为第2阶段。使用单向方差分析比较各组之间的第2阶段总活动。
与对照组相比,在第1阶段接受氟烷、恩氟烷、异氟烷、地氟烷或氧化亚氮的动物在第2阶段的活动显著降低,而接受氧化亚氮和氟烷组合的动物则无差异。与对照组相比,在第1阶段接受静脉硫喷妥钠麻醉的动物在第2阶段的活动无差异,而在第1阶段接受丙泊酚的动物在第2阶段的活动显著降低。
挥发性麻醉剂或氧化亚氮可显著抑制脊髓敏化,而氧化亚氮加氟烷的组合则无抑制作用。硫喷妥钠不影响脊髓敏化,而丙泊酚则有显著抑制作用。这些结果可能对术后疼痛的发生具有重要意义。