Iinuma T, Hirota Y, Kase Y
Department of Otolaryngology, Saitama Medical College, Japan.
Rhinology. 1994 Sep;32(3):134-6.
In order to examine the reliability of conventional views in predicting the degree of radio-opacity, irrespective of soft tissue or fluid seen in chronic sinusitis in adults, a comparison has been made between the results of evaluations by two routine views (Caldwell's and Waters') and by CT in axial scans. Ninety-seven sides (61 case) were included in the study. The radio-opacity was classified into three groups according to the degree of aeration or radiolucency. The diagnosis of plain films were classified into three categories (matched diagnosis, over-diagnosis, and under-diagnosis) in comparison to the radio-opacity depicted by corresponding CT scans. The incidences of matched diagnosis are, in the order of percentages: maxillary sinus (78.4%), frontal sinus (71.1%), nasofrontal area (66.0%), anterior ethmoidal cells (52.6%), and posterior ethmoidal cells (52.6%). The incidence of over-diagnosis is highest in the posterior ethmoidal cells (52.6%) and lowest in the maxillary sinus (20.6%). The incidence of under-diagnosis is highest in the anterior ethmoidal cells (24.7%) and lowest in the maxillary sinus (1.0%).
为了检验传统观点在预测不透射线程度方面的可靠性,而不考虑成人慢性鼻窦炎中所见的软组织或液体,对两种常规视图(柯氏位和瓦氏位)与轴向扫描CT的评估结果进行了比较。该研究纳入了97侧(61例)。根据通气程度或透亮度将不透射线程度分为三组。与相应CT扫描显示的不透射线程度相比,平片诊断分为三类(匹配诊断、过度诊断和诊断不足)。匹配诊断的发生率按百分比顺序为:上颌窦(78.4%)、额窦(71.1%)、鼻额区(66.0%)、前筛窦(52.6%)和后筛窦(52.6%)。过度诊断的发生率在后筛窦最高(52.6%),在上颌窦最低(20.6%)。诊断不足的发生率在前筛窦最高(24.7%),在上颌窦最低(1.0%)。