Haggerty P A, Muladi K, Kirkwood B R, Ashworth A, Manunebo M
Centre for Human Nutrition, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK.
Int J Epidemiol. 1994 Oct;23(5):1050-9. doi: 10.1093/ije/23.5.1050.
Diarrhoeal disease is a leading cause of morbidity in young children in rural Zaire. Few diarrhoea prevention programmes have been implemented in Bandundu Province, where available data suggest an annual prevalence rate of 10%. The urgent need to reduce diarrhoeal morbidity in Zaire, together with the potential effectiveness and feasibility of hygiene education as a diarrhoea prevention strategy, led to the development of the present research project.
A randomized, controlled trial of an education intervention to reduce diarrhoea through improved personal and domestic hygiene behaviours was conducted in 18 geographically separate village clusters (sites) in rural Zaire. For 12 weeks baseline information on the diarrhoeal morbidity of 2082 children aged 3-35 months was collected at weekly home visits, and structured observations of hygiene practices related to diarrhoea were made on a subset of 300 families. Intervention messages addressed disposal of animal faeces from the yard, handwashing after defecation and before meal preparation and eating, and disposal of children's faeces. Three months after the start of the intervention and exactly 1 year after the baseline studies, a second diarrhoeal morbidity study and a second observational study were conducted in order to evaluate the intervention.
Children in intervention communities experienced an 11% reduction in the risk of reporting diarrhoea during the peak diarrhoeal season, compared to controls (P < 0.025). The largest differences were seen among children aged 24-35 months, with those from intervention communities reporting significantly fewer episodes, shorter mean durations and hence fewer days of diarrhoea. There was some evidence that greater reductions in diarrhoea occurred in sites where the quality of the intervention, a scored measure of volunteer efficacy and community participation, was highest.
The results of this study suggest that hygiene education may be an effective approach to reduce the incidence and duration of diarrhoeal episodes in rural Zaire. Children aged 2 years appear to benefit the most. A Hawthorne effect of the education may contribute to diarrhoeal reductions.
腹泻病是扎伊尔农村地区幼儿发病的主要原因。在班顿杜省,很少有腹泻预防项目得到实施,现有数据表明该省的年患病率为10%。扎伊尔迫切需要降低腹泻发病率,而卫生教育作为一种腹泻预防策略具有潜在的有效性和可行性,这促使了本研究项目的开展。
在扎伊尔农村地区18个地理上分散的村庄集群(地点)进行了一项随机对照试验,该教育干预旨在通过改善个人和家庭卫生行为来减少腹泻。在为期12周的时间里,每周进行家访,收集2082名3至35个月大儿童腹泻发病情况的基线信息,并对300个家庭的子集进行与腹泻相关的卫生习惯的结构化观察。干预信息涉及院子里动物粪便的处理、排便后和准备饭菜及吃饭前的洗手以及儿童粪便的处理。干预开始三个月后以及基线研究正好一年后,进行了第二次腹泻发病情况研究和第二次观察性研究,以评估干预效果。
与对照组相比,干预社区的儿童在腹泻高发季节报告腹泻的风险降低了11%(P < 0.025)。在24至35个月大的儿童中差异最为明显,干预社区的儿童报告的腹泻发作次数明显减少,平均持续时间更短,因此腹泻天数也更少。有证据表明,在干预质量(志愿者效能和社区参与的评分衡量指标)最高的地点,腹泻减少得更多。
本研究结果表明,卫生教育可能是降低扎伊尔农村地区腹泻发作的发生率和持续时间的有效方法。两岁的儿童似乎受益最大。教育的霍桑效应可能有助于减少腹泻。