Stephen K W
Department of Adult Dental Care, University of Glasgow, Dental School, Scotland.
Adv Dent Res. 1994 Jul;8(2):185-9. doi: 10.1177/08959374940080020901.
Only from the mid-1950's has therapeutic benefit been obtained via dentifrices, initially with stannous fluoride-then monofluorophosphate-containing products which remained stable and efficacious. Altered abrasive systems followed, and both sodium fluoride and monofluorophosphate/sodium fluoride mixtures were introduced as active anti-caries agents, with recent meta-analysis indicating that sodium fluoride > monofluorophosphate/sodium fluoride > monofluorophosphate. With respect to fluoride levels, clear dose-response relationships have been demonstrated. However, at < 1000 ppm F, the situation is less certain. Since the mid-1980's, anticalculus fluoride dentifrices have been marketed, and have been shown to have similar caries-reducing potential as their non-calculus-inhibiting control formulae. Finally, one study has been described where a sodium fluoride dentifrice successfully reduced root caries. Of the many fluoride formulations used for caries-inhibiting mouthrinsing [e.g., acid phosphate fluoride (100-3000 ppm F), sodium fluoride (45-3000 ppm F), stannous fluoride (100-250 ppm F), ammonium fluoride (1000 ppm F), and amine fluoride (250 ppm F)], sodium fluoride would seem to be the preferred agent. Furthermore, rinse frequency is deemed more important than fluoride ion concentration, but caution is urged re the volumes and concentrations to be used by children, no rinsing being recommended below 4 years. Combination of a 440-pp-F sodium fluoride and 0.05% chlorhexidine school-administered rinse appears to have increased the caries-inhibiting benefit as compared with sodium fluoride alone. Fluoride supplements have reduced deciduous caries from 14 to 93%, and in the permanent dentition, from 20 to 81%.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
直到20世纪50年代中期,牙膏才开始产生治疗效果,最初是含氟化亚锡的产品,随后是含单氟磷酸钠的产品,这些产品一直保持稳定且有效。后来出现了改良的研磨体系,氟化钠和单氟磷酸钠/氟化钠混合物作为活性防龋剂被引入,最近的荟萃分析表明,氟化钠>单氟磷酸钠/氟化钠>单氟磷酸钠。关于氟含量,已证明存在明确的剂量反应关系。然而,在氟含量<1000 ppm时,情况不太确定。自20世纪80年代中期以来,防牙石含氟牙膏已投放市场,并且已证明其具有与不含抑制牙石的对照配方相似的减少龋齿的潜力。最后,有一项研究表明,一种含氟化钠的牙膏成功减少了根龋。在用于防龋漱口水的众多氟制剂中[例如酸性磷酸氟(100 - 3000 ppm F)、氟化钠(45 - 3000 ppm F)、氟化亚锡(100 - 250 ppm F)、氟化铵(1000 ppm F)和氟化胺(250 ppm F)],氟化钠似乎是首选制剂。此外,漱口频率被认为比氟离子浓度更重要,但对于儿童使用的体积和浓度需谨慎,不建议4岁以下儿童漱口。与单独使用氟化钠相比,学校提供的含440 ppm F的氟化钠和0.05%洗必泰的漱口水组合似乎增加了防龋益处。氟补充剂已使乳牙龋齿减少了14%至93%,恒牙龋齿减少了20%至81%。(摘要截选至250字)