Davis Karen D, Hutchison William D, Lozano Andres M, Dostrovsky Jonathan O
Division of Neurosurgery, Toronto Hospital (Western Division) Toronto, Ontario M5S 1A8 Canada Department of Physiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S 1A8 Canada.
Pain. 1994 Nov;59(2):189-199. doi: 10.1016/0304-3959(94)90071-X.
Recent studies have renewed interest in the role of limbic structures, such as the cingulate cortex, in nociception. To investigate the involvement of the limbic system in pain and temperature perception further, we have quantified ratings of innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli in a patient with schizoaffective disorder before and after 2 surgical procedures. Psychophysical tests were conducted at a control session prior to surgery. Postoperative test sessions were conducted up to 10 weeks after bilateral cingulotomy and for 3 months after a subsequent bilateral anterior internal capsulotomy. A contact thermal stimulator delivered ascending (39-50 degrees C) and descending (22-2 degrees C) series of stimuli to the patient's volar forearm. The patient was trained to rate the innocuous warmth and cold and the pain associated with each stimulus. A cold pressor test was used to obtain a measure of cold pain tolerance. Compared to pre-operative levels, cingulotomy/capsulotomy resulted in moderately diminished warmth perception and an elevated heat pain threshold and increased ratings to suprathreshold noxious heat stimuli (hyperpathia). Prior to surgery, the patient perceived all cold stimuli as cold but not painful. However, after cingulotomy and capsulotomy, cold stimuli were rated significantly colder and stimuli less than or equal to 12 degrees C evoked pain. Compared to normal control subjects, the patient's ratings of innocuous and noxious cold stimuli were reduced pre-operatively but elevated postoperatively and cold pain tolerance was elevated pre-operatively but reduced postoperatively. These altered ratings of noxious heat and cold stimuli were reflected on both a pain intensity and pain affect (unpleasantness) scale. In summary, these data suggest that cingulotomy and capsulotomy disinhibited the patient's noxious heat and cold appreciation. These findings provide support for a role of the cingulate cortex and frontal cortical regions in the perception of innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli and suggest that under normal conditions, these areas may act to suppress the subjective intensity of noxious heat and cold.
最近的研究重新引发了人们对边缘结构(如扣带回皮质)在伤害感受中作用的兴趣。为了进一步研究边缘系统在疼痛和温度感知中的参与情况,我们对一名分裂情感性障碍患者在两次外科手术前后无害和有害热刺激的评分进行了量化。在手术前的对照期进行了心理物理学测试。双侧扣带回切开术后长达10周以及随后双侧内囊前肢切开术后3个月进行了术后测试。一个接触式热刺激器向患者的掌侧前臂传递递增(39 - 50摄氏度)和递减(22 - 2摄氏度)的刺激系列。患者接受训练,对无害的温暖和寒冷以及与每个刺激相关的疼痛进行评分。使用冷加压试验来获得冷痛耐受性的测量值。与术前水平相比,扣带回切开术/内囊切开术导致温暖感知适度降低,热痛阈值升高,对阈上有害热刺激的评分增加(痛觉过敏)。手术前,患者将所有冷刺激都感知为冷但不疼痛。然而,在扣带回切开术和内囊切开术后,冷刺激被评为明显更冷,小于或等于12摄氏度的刺激会引起疼痛。与正常对照受试者相比,患者术前对无害和有害冷刺激的评分降低,但术后升高,冷痛耐受性术前升高但术后降低。这些对有害热和冷刺激评分的改变在疼痛强度和疼痛情感(不愉快)量表上均有体现。总之,这些数据表明扣带回切开术和内囊切开术解除了患者对有害热和冷的感知抑制。这些发现为扣带回皮质和额叶皮质区域在无害和有害热刺激感知中的作用提供了支持,并表明在正常情况下,这些区域可能起到抑制有害热和冷主观强度的作用。