Ottman R, Lipton R B
G.H. Sergievsky Center, School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, NY 10032.
Neurology. 1994 Nov;44(11):2105-10. doi: 10.1212/wnl.44.11.2105.
We investigated comorbidity of migraine and epilepsy by using information from structured telephone interviews with 1,948 adult probands with epilepsy and 1,411 of their parents and siblings. Epilepsy was defined as a lifetime history of two or more unprovoked seizures, and migraine as severe headaches with two or more of the following symptoms: unilateral pain, throbbing pain, visual aura, or nausea. Cumulative incidence of migraine to age 40 was 24% in probands with epilepsy, 23% in relatives with epilepsy, and 12% in relatives without epilepsy. Using Cox proportional hazards analysis to control for years at risk and gender, the rate ratio for migraine was 2.4 (95% CI, 2.02 to 2.89) among probands and 2.4 (1.58 to 3.79) among relatives with epilepsy in comparison with relatives without epilepsy. Migraine risk was highest in probands with epilepsy due to head trauma, but it was significantly higher in every subgroup of probands than in unaffected relatives when probands were stratified by seizure type, age at onset, etiology of epilepsy, and history of epilepsy in first-degree relatives. Age-specific incidence of migraine among probands was increased to a greater extent after onset of epilepsy than before, but it was also significantly increased more than 5 years before onset and 1 to 5 years before onset. These results indicate that migraine and epilepsy are strongly associated, independent of seizure type, etiology, age at onset, or family history of epilepsy.
我们通过对1948名成年癫痫先证者及其1411名父母和兄弟姐妹进行结构化电话访谈获取信息,对偏头痛与癫痫的共病情况进行了调查。癫痫被定义为有两次或更多次无诱因发作的终生病史,偏头痛则定义为伴有以下两种或更多症状的严重头痛:单侧疼痛、搏动性疼痛、视觉先兆或恶心。癫痫先证者中偏头痛至40岁的累积发病率为24%,癫痫亲属中为23%,无癫痫亲属中为12%。使用Cox比例风险分析以控制风险年限和性别,与无癫痫亲属相比,癫痫先证者中偏头痛的发生率比值为2.4(95%可信区间,2.02至2.89),癫痫亲属中为2.4(1.58至3.79)。因头部外伤导致癫痫的先证者偏头痛风险最高,但当先证者按发作类型、发病年龄、癫痫病因以及一级亲属的癫痫病史进行分层时,每个先证者亚组中的偏头痛风险均显著高于未受影响的亲属。癫痫先证者中偏头痛的年龄别发病率在癫痫发作后比发作前升高幅度更大,但在发作前5年以上以及发作前1至5年也显著升高。这些结果表明,偏头痛与癫痫密切相关,与发作类型、病因、发病年龄或癫痫家族史无关。