Scarr S, Weinberg R A
Department of Psychology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville 22903.
Behav Genet. 1994 Jul;24(4):301-25. doi: 10.1007/BF01067532.
The study of brothers and sisters from adoptive and biologically related families permits unique analyses of the determinants of young adults' educational and occupational achievements. Brothers and sisters come from the same homes, neighborhoods, and usually schools. Many differences among families are controlled by the study of siblings. In addition, adoptive families influence their children only through the environment they provide, whereas biologically related parents transmit their intellectual and personal characteristics to their offspring genetically as well. Thus, the comparison of models of adult achievements for children from adoptive and biologically related families can inform us about the true effects of family environments, apart from genetic transmission (Scarr and Weinberg, 1978, 1980). In this follow-up study of 450 biologically related and adopted young adults (ages 22 to 30 years), we report on the family resemblances in educational and occupational achievements. Parents' reports were obtained on 97% of the original sample (N = 443), and 77% of the young adults participated in the follow-up study themselves; complete educational and occupational data were available on 303 young adults. Results show that biological sons are more influenced by their family backgrounds than daughters, regardless of genetic relatedness. A second finding is that young women's achievements are not as predictable from their own earlier achievements as are those of their brothers. A third finding is that parents invest in their sons' educational futures, regardless of sons' abilities and achievements, in ways they do not invest in their daughters' postsecondary educations. Sibling correlations and natural mother-adopted child correlations suggest that test scores, high school performance, postsecondary education, and even later occupational status can be influenced by genetic variability in personal characteristics that affect such achievements.
对来自收养家庭和亲生家庭的兄弟姐妹进行研究,有助于对年轻人的教育和职业成就的决定因素进行独特的分析。兄弟姐妹来自相同的家庭、社区,通常还就读于同一所学校。通过对兄弟姐妹的研究,可以控制家庭之间的许多差异。此外,收养家庭仅通过他们提供的环境来影响孩子,而亲生父母则会将自己的智力和个人特征通过基因传递给后代。因此,比较收养家庭和亲生家庭中孩子的成人成就模型,可以让我们了解除基因传递外家庭环境的真实影响(斯卡和温伯格,1978年,1980年)。在这项对450名亲生和收养的年轻人(年龄在22至30岁之间)的随访研究中,我们报告了教育和职业成就方面的家庭相似性。获得了97%的原始样本(N = 443)中父母的报告,77%的年轻人亲自参与了随访研究;303名年轻人有完整的教育和职业数据。结果表明,无论基因关系如何,亲生儿子比女儿更容易受到家庭背景的影响。第二个发现是,年轻女性的成就不像她们兄弟的成就那样可以根据她们自己早期的成就来预测。第三个发现是,父母在儿子的教育未来方面进行投资,无论儿子的能力和成就如何,而在女儿的高等教育方面却没有这样做。兄弟姐妹之间的相关性以及亲生母亲与收养孩子之间的相关性表明,测试分数、高中成绩、高等教育,甚至后来的职业地位都可能受到影响这些成就的个人特征的基因变异性的影响。