Brotherton S E
Division of Research on Health Policy, American Academy of Pediatrics, Elk Grove Village, IL 60009-0927.
Pediatrics. 1994 Jul;94(1):83-9.
To examine the extent of pediatric subspecialty training, certification, and practice among general and subspecialty pediatricians and to determine how the diversity of pediatric careers may affect physician workforce supply estimates.
A sample of 4,000 self-designated pediatricians and pediatric subspecialists from the American Medical Association's Physician Masterfile were surveyed in 1991 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. Seventy-six percent of the sample responded to the 6-page questionnaire on practice characteristics, training, and demographic information.
Two-thirds of pediatricians are not subspecialty trained (66.3%), 15.1% are certified subspecialists, 11.3% are trained but not subboard certified, and 7.3% are subspecialty trained in an area with no certification exam. Subspecialty training did not always predict subspecialty practice; 19% of pediatricians without subspecialty training spend some time in a subspecialty, and 13% of those who are subspecialty trained practice general pediatrics exclusively. Certified subspecialists and those who cannot as yet become certified are most likely to practice their subspecialty. One-fourth of those trained in a certifiable subspecialty but who remain uncertified practice general pediatrics exclusively. The proportion of direct patient care time spent overall, and the proportion of direct patient care time spent in the subspecialty are also related to subspecialty certification and training/practice consistency.
Pediatric workforce supply projections should incorporate more than certification and training information in calculating estimates, as the practice of general and subspecialty pediatrics is very diverse and accommodating of integrative styles.
研究普通儿科医生和儿科专科医生在儿科亚专业培训、认证及实践方面的情况,并确定儿科职业的多样性如何影响医生劳动力供应估计。
1991年,美国儿科学会对美国医学协会医生主文件中抽取的4000名自称为儿科医生和儿科亚专科医生的样本进行了调查。76%的样本回复了这份长达6页的关于实践特征、培训和人口统计学信息的问卷。
三分之二的儿科医生未接受亚专业培训(66.3%),15.1%为获得认证的亚专科医生,11.3%接受过培训但未通过亚专科委员会认证,7.3%在没有认证考试的领域接受过亚专业培训。亚专业培训并不总是能预测亚专业实践;19%未接受亚专业培训的儿科医生会花一些时间从事亚专业工作,而13%接受过亚专业培训的医生只从事普通儿科工作。获得认证的亚专科医生以及那些尚未获得认证的医生最有可能从事他们的亚专业工作。在可认证的亚专业接受培训但仍未获得认证的医生中,四分之一的人只从事普通儿科工作。总体上直接用于患者护理的时间比例,以及在亚专业中直接用于患者护理的时间比例,也与亚专业认证以及培训/实践的一致性有关。
儿科劳动力供应预测在计算估计数时应纳入比认证和培训信息更多的内容,因为普通儿科和儿科亚专业的实践非常多样,且包容综合模式。