Nigg H N, Radulescu G
Citrus Research and Education Center, University of Florida, Lake Alfred 33850.
JAMA. 1994 Jul 13;272(2):168-70.
Scientific misconduct easily occurs in environmental science and toxicology; we encountered four such cases. Only one case was discovered by editors; three were reported by other authors. All guilty authors were eventually banned from future publication in the Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. Cases in the Bulletin indicate that scientific misconduct may occur undetected across phyla, genera, and species; that distance from the publishing source makes detection more difficult; that editors and reviewers are not organized to take action against scientific misconduct; that plagiarized authors are likely to report plagiarism; and that there is only a small risk of censure from any source for authors engaging in scientific misconduct.
科学不端行为在环境科学和毒理学领域很容易发生;我们就遇到了四起这样的案例。只有一起案例是由编辑发现的;三起是由其他作者举报的。所有有过错的作者最终都被禁止在《环境污染与毒理学通报》上发表未来的文章。该通报中的案例表明,科学不端行为可能在各个门类、属和物种中未被发现地发生;与出版源头的距离使得发现更加困难;编辑和审稿人没有组织起来对科学不端行为采取行动;被抄袭的作者很可能会举报抄袭行为;而且从事科学不端行为的作者受到任何来源谴责的风险都很小。