Richardson J T
Department of Human Sciences, Brunel University, Uxbridge, Middlesex, United Kingdom.
Percept Mot Skills. 1994 Apr;78(2):435-48. doi: 10.2466/pms.1994.78.2.435.
Two experiments were carried out to compare the performance of male and female students at different educational levels on tasks that required mental rotation. Exp. 1 also compared their performance on an overt, male-typed version and a disguised, female-typed version of the same task. Amongst introductory undergraduate students, men performed significantly better than women, but this difference was as pronounced on the disguised, female-typed version as on the overt, male-typed task. However, there was no sign of any gender difference on the overt task in advanced undergraduate and postgraduate students. The latter finding was not replicated in Exp. 2, in which significant effects of gender regardless of the students' educational level were noted. Nevertheless, the effect size was significantly smaller than that obtained for comparable students tested on the same task during the 1970s. Taken together, these results confirm that gender differences in at least some aspects of mental rotation may be abolished by educational experience and that gender differences in mental rotation have become smaller over the last 20 years. Such findings favor sociocultural explanations of gender differences in mental rotation rather than biological explanations.
进行了两项实验,以比较不同教育水平的男、女学生在需要心理旋转的任务中的表现。实验1还比较了他们在同一任务的公开的、男性化版本和伪装的、女性化版本上的表现。在本科新生中,男性的表现明显优于女性,但这种差异在伪装的、女性化版本上与公开的、男性化任务上一样明显。然而,在高年级本科生和研究生中,公开任务上没有任何性别差异的迹象。后一项发现并未在实验2中得到重复,在实验2中,无论学生的教育水平如何,都发现了显著的性别效应。尽管如此,效应大小明显小于20世纪70年代对在同一任务上进行测试的可比学生所获得的效应大小。综合来看,这些结果证实,至少在心理旋转的某些方面,性别差异可能会被教育经历消除,并且在过去20年中,心理旋转方面的性别差异已经变小。这些发现支持了对心理旋转中性别差异的社会文化解释,而非生物学解释。