Hauser R, Garcia-Closas M, Kelsey K T, Christiani D C
Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts.
Arch Environ Health. 1994 Jul-Aug;49(4):267-72. doi: 10.1080/00039896.1994.9937478.
Recent studies have utilized nasal lavage to study the inflammatory cells of the nasal epithelium. In unexposed subjects, investigators have reported wide interindividual variability in lavage cell counts. The intraindividual variability of cell counts in sequential lavages has been less well described. Investigators have also reported that nasal lavage may washout cells, resulting in lower cell counts on subsequent lavages. The present study was designed to characterize both the variability in cell counts in unexposed volunteers and the kinetics of cell washout. Twenty-one subjects participated in two nasal lavage trials. In Trial 1, a baseline lavage was followed by a lavage 72 h later; in Trial 2, the baseline lavage was followed by a lavage 48 h later. Intraclass correlation coefficients of reliability (R) were calculated for each trial. In Trial 1, the R was 0.88, with a one-sided confidence interval > or = 0.75, whereas in Trial 2 R was 0.67, with a confidence interval > or = 0.40. The smaller R in Trial 2 may suggest that washout was more evident at 48 h than at 72 h after the baseline lavage. Furthermore, these R values suggest that within-subject variability is smaller than between-subject variability, supporting the utility of nasal lavage as a reliable technique for investigating the nasal cavity response to air pollutants.
最近的研究利用鼻腔灌洗来研究鼻上皮的炎症细胞。在未暴露于污染物的受试者中,研究人员报告称灌洗细胞计数存在很大的个体间差异。而连续灌洗中细胞计数的个体内差异则较少被描述。研究人员还报告说,鼻腔灌洗可能会冲走细胞,导致后续灌洗时细胞计数降低。本研究旨在描述未暴露志愿者细胞计数的变异性以及细胞清除的动力学。21名受试者参与了两项鼻腔灌洗试验。在试验1中,先进行一次基线灌洗,72小时后再进行一次灌洗;在试验2中,基线灌洗后48小时进行一次灌洗。计算了每项试验的组内相关可靠性系数(R)。在试验1中,R为0.88,单侧置信区间≥0.75,而在试验2中,R为0.67,置信区间≥0.40。试验2中较小的R可能表明,在基线灌洗后48小时的清除比72小时更明显。此外,这些R值表明,受试者内变异性小于受试者间变异性,支持鼻腔灌洗作为一种可靠技术用于研究鼻腔对空气污染物反应的实用性。