Wakefield D S, Cyphert S T, Murray J F, Uden-Holman T, Hendryx M S, Wakefield B J, Helms C M
Graduate Program in Hospital and Health Administration, University of Iowa, Iowa City 52242.
Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1994 Mar;20(3):152-61. doi: 10.1016/s1070-3241(16)30058-x.
Implementing patient-centered care (PCC) requires a fundamental shift in thinking-from how to best provide a wide variety of independent services to how to effectively combine individual service components into an integrated health care experience that meets patient needs and preferences.
PCC attempts to improve patient care by organizationally and physically moving selected service functions such as basic laboratory, pharmacy, admitting/discharge, medical records, housekeeping, and material support services to patient care areas, thus effecting an organizational restructuring. PCC creates teams composed of multiskilled or cross-trained individuals capable of providing more of the services directly on the patient care unit. Extensive redesign of the basic work processes as proposed by PCC advocates may result in significant changes in employee job scope, task responsibilities, professional autonomy, and reporting relationships. From the employee's perspective such changes may be neither warranted nor welcomed. Therefore, critical PCC implementation issues include obtaining employee buy-in and establishing appropriate incentive structures to facilitate the desired changes. How does PCC fit in with the popular improvement philosophies of total quality management (TQM) and continuous quality improvement (CQI)? Inherent within TQM and CQI is the belief that it is wiser to maximize efforts to design a product or process to be right the first time and to minimize resources devoted to inspection and repair caused by poor processes. PCC builds upon previous TQM/CQI health care efforts by focusing on ways to reduce the white space handoff problem by examining what, if any, changes in underlying structures and processes may be required. In the PCC hospital, TQM/CQI can function as intended, as a methodology for examining and improving the process of care and patient-care outcomes, regardless of internal departmental or profession-based organizational boundaries.
For hospitals to remain competitive in today's rapidly changing environment, it is becoming necessary to reevaluate both how they are organized and how their work processes have been designed and controlled. The groundwork already laid by TQM/CQI initiatives will facilitate the more fundamental and long-lasting improvements derived from the redesign of the patient-care unit as prescribed by the goals of PCC.
实施以患者为中心的护理(PCC)需要思维上的根本转变——从如何最好地提供各种各样的独立服务,转变为如何有效地将各个服务组件整合为一种能满足患者需求和偏好的综合医疗体验。
PCC试图通过将诸如基础实验室、药房、入院/出院、病历、家政和物资支持服务等选定的服务功能在组织上和物理上转移到患者护理区域来改善患者护理,从而实现组织架构的重组。PCC创建由多技能或经过交叉培训的人员组成的团队,这些人员能够在患者护理单元直接提供更多服务。PCC倡导者提议的对基本工作流程的广泛重新设计可能会导致员工工作范围、任务职责、职业自主权和汇报关系发生重大变化。从员工的角度来看,这些变化可能既不合理也不受欢迎。因此,PCC实施的关键问题包括获得员工的认同以及建立适当的激励机制以促成期望的变革。PCC如何与全面质量管理(TQM)和持续质量改进(CQI)这些流行的改进理念相契合?TQM和CQI内在的信念是,更明智的做法是最大限度地努力使产品或流程在首次设计时就是正确的,并尽量减少因流程不佳而投入到检查和修复上的资源。PCC在先前TQM/CQI的医疗保健工作基础上,通过研究可能需要对底层结构和流程进行哪些改变(如果有的话)来减少空白交接问题。在PCC医院中,TQM/CQI能够按预期发挥作用,作为一种检查和改进护理过程及患者护理结果的方法,而不受内部部门或基于专业的组织界限的限制。
为了在当今快速变化的环境中保持竞争力,医院有必要重新评估其组织方式以及工作流程的设计和控制方式。TQM/CQI举措已经奠定的基础将有助于实现PCC目标所规定的对患者护理单元进行重新设计而带来的更根本、更持久的改进。