Breitner J C, Welsh K A, Robinette C D, Gau B A, Folstein M F, Brandt J
Department of Psychiatry, Duke University School of Medicine, Durham, N.C.
Dementia. 1994 Mar-Apr;5(2):99-105. doi: 10.1159/000106703.
Over 3 years we followed 8 pairs of male twins one or both of whom had suspected Alzheimer's disease (AD) including 'mild/ambiguous' changes suggestive of incident AD. These pairs were screened in 1988 and 1989 from 339 pairs in the (US) National Academy of Sciences-National Research Council Registry (NASR) of aging veteran twins, then 61-72 years of age. Most of the suspected cases (10 of 12) had mild/ambiguous changes. Including these subjects, we had estimated the prevalence of AD in the NASR as about 2%. We now describe briefly the longitudinal evaluation of these 8 pairs. Only 1 of the 10 individuals with mild/ambiguous changes has progressed to show well-defined clinical symptoms of AD. Two others remain in their original research category, while 7 clearly do not have AD. Thus, we now estimate the 1988-1989 prevalence of AD in the NASR as 0.5%. These results contrast with other follow-up studies of mild cases from a university-based Alzheimer's clinic. We suggest that the contrasting findings reflect the nature of the samples studied, and we show that the present results are predicted by Bayesian reasoning.
在3年多的时间里,我们跟踪了8对男性双胞胎,其中一对或双方都疑似患有阿尔茨海默病(AD),包括提示新发AD的“轻度/不明确”变化。这些双胞胎对是在1988年和1989年从(美国)国家科学院-国家研究委员会老年退伍军人双胞胎登记处(NASR)的339对双胞胎中筛选出来的,当时他们的年龄在61至72岁之间。大多数疑似病例(12例中的10例)有轻度/不明确的变化。包括这些受试者在内,我们估计NASR中AD的患病率约为2%。我们现在简要描述这8对双胞胎的纵向评估情况。10例有轻度/不明确变化的个体中只有1例进展为出现明确的AD临床症状。另外2例仍处于原来的研究分类中,而7例显然没有患AD。因此,我们现在估计1988 - 1989年NASR中AD的患病率为0.5%。这些结果与来自一家大学阿尔茨海默病诊所对轻度病例的其他随访研究结果形成对比。我们认为,这些对比结果反映了所研究样本的性质,并且我们表明目前的结果可以通过贝叶斯推理预测出来。