Piloni V, Pomerri F, Platania E, Pieri L, Pinto F, Gasparini G, Genovesi N, Di Giandomenico E, Grassi R, Salzano A
Istituto Geriatrico, Fermo, Ascoli Piceno.
Radiol Med. 1994 Jun;87(6):789-95.
The nonoperative treatment--i.e., rubber band ligation and sclerotherapy--of mucous rectal prolapse, rectocele and intussusception is much less expensive than conventional surgery (Lit. 325,000 vs. 6,500,000, p < 0.0001 on the average). Symptom relief, however, has been reported in 0 to 57% of cases only, according to current literature. A possible cause is represented by improper management from misdiagnosis, relying on clinical findings only, overestimating mucous prolapse in 36.37% of cases and underestimating intussusception in 14.22% of cases (with respect to defecography). Defecography is a cost-effective method (average cost: Lit. 37,000) potentially reducing failure rate after the surgical repair of rectal prolapse.
直肠黏膜脱垂、直肠膨出和肠套叠的非手术治疗——即橡皮筋结扎术和硬化疗法——比传统手术便宜得多(平均费用分别为32.5万意大利里拉和650万里拉,p < 0.0001)。然而,根据现有文献报道,仅0%至57%的病例症状得到缓解。一个可能的原因是管理不当,仅依靠临床检查结果进行误诊,36.37%的病例高估了黏膜脱垂,14.22%的病例低估了肠套叠(相对于排粪造影检查)。排粪造影是一种性价比高的方法(平均费用:3.7万里拉),有可能降低直肠脱垂手术修复后的失败率。