Fenton W S, Wyatt R J, McGlashan T H
Chesnut Lodge Research Institute, Rockville, Md.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1994 Aug;51(8):643-50. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1994.03950080055008.
We describe the prevalence, clinical correlates, and prognostic significance of spontaneous dyskinesias among 100 patients with schizophrenia from the Chestnut Lodge Follow-up Study who had never received treatment with neuroleptic agents up to and including the baseline assessment.
Extensive case records were screened and descriptions of abnormal movements were recorded verbatim for blind rating. Neuroleptic-naive patients with and without abnormal oral-facial movements were compared across sign and symptom, schizophrenia subtype, and illness natural history variables.
Excluding three patients with motor symptoms who had a history of neurologic illness or injury and three who had received prochlorperazine maleate therapy (Compazine), 23% of patient records documented some form of movement disorder; 15% documented oral-facial dyskinesias with sufficient detail so that their presence was considered nearly certain. Compared with patients with schizophrenia without oral-facial movements, patients with oral-facial dyskinesias were more likely to demonstrate a lower IQ score, had more negative symptoms at index admission, and were more symptomatic at follow-up an average of 23 years later. Both the classic hebephrenic schizophrenia subtype and Carpenter's Criteria for the Deficit Syndrome defined high-risk groups for spontaneous oral-facial dyskinesia.
In previous studies, intellectual impairment and negative symptoms have been described as risk factors for neuroleptic-induced tardive dyskinesia. The present data, however, suggest that in many cases oral-facial dyskinesias in patients with intellectual impairment and negative symptoms may actually represent spontaneous movement disorders associated with hebephrenic or deficit forms of schizophrenia.
我们描述了来自栗树屋随访研究的100例精神分裂症患者中自发运动障碍的患病率、临床相关性及预后意义,这些患者在基线评估及之前从未接受过抗精神病药物治疗。
对大量病例记录进行筛查,并逐字记录异常运动的描述以供盲法评分。对有无异常口面部运动的未服用过抗精神病药物的患者,在体征和症状、精神分裂症亚型及疾病自然史变量方面进行比较。
排除3例有神经系统疾病或损伤史的有运动症状患者以及3例接受过马来酸丙氯拉嗪治疗(康帕嗪)的患者,23%的患者记录显示存在某种形式的运动障碍;15%的记录对口面部运动障碍有足够详细的描述,因此其存在几乎可以确定。与无口面部运动的精神分裂症患者相比,有口面部运动障碍的患者智商得分更低,入院时阴性症状更多,且在平均23年后的随访中症状更明显。经典的青春型精神分裂症亚型和卡彭特缺陷综合征标准均确定了自发口面部运动障碍的高危组。
在以往研究中,智力损害和阴性症状被描述为抗精神病药物所致迟发性运动障碍的危险因素。然而,目前的数据表明,在许多情况下,有智力损害和阴性症状患者的口面部运动障碍可能实际上代表了与青春型或缺陷型精神分裂症相关的自发运动障碍。