McClements B M, Campbell N P, Cochrane D, Stockman S
Regional Medical Cardiology Centre, Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Br Heart J. 1994 Jun;71(6):531-5. doi: 10.1136/hrt.71.6.531.
To assess the safety and value of an exercise electrocardiography service for the diagnosis of suspected ischaemic heart disease to which general practitioners have direct access.
Direct access to a hospital exercise electrocardiography service was offered on a trial basis to 122 general practitioners in a defined urban area. Maximal exercise tests were performed according to the modified Bruce protocol and the results were dispatched promptly to the referring doctors who were responsible for the subsequent management of their patients.
All general practices in north and west Belfast (combined list size about 180,000) and the regional medical cardiology centre.
212 request forms were received in a two year period and 192 eligible patients attended for exercise testing. All patients were suspected to have pain due to myocardial ischaemia, were aged < or = 65, and had no contraindications to exercise testing.
Proportion of general practitioners who used the service. Proportion of exercise tests that were positive. Referring doctors' assessment of the service.
43% of general practitioners referred patients and 34 tests (18%) were positive. No complications occurred. The pretest likelihood of ischaemic heart disease, assessed by the referring doctor, was high in 48 (25%), moderate in 82 (43%), and low in 62 (32%). A high pretest likelihood of ischaemic heart disease predicted a positive test result with a sensitivity of 50% and specificity of 80%. General practitioners decided to refer 19 (10%) patients to a hospital cardiology department for further assessment, including 16 of the 34 who had a positive exercise test. In most cases the service was found to be helpful and 97% of patients would have been referred directly to a hospital cardiology clinic if it had not been available.
Direct access exercise electrocardiography for patients with suspected ischaemic heart disease is safe, feasible, and helpful to general practitioners. This service seems to reduce the number of patients referred to cardiology outpatient clinics and to facilitate the management of these patients in the community.
评估一项运动心电图服务对于诊断疑似缺血性心脏病的安全性和价值,该服务可供全科医生直接使用。
在一个特定城区,对122名全科医生进行了一项试验性的直接使用医院运动心电图服务的研究。根据改良的布鲁斯方案进行最大运动试验,并将结果迅速发送给负责后续患者管理的转诊医生。
北贝尔法斯特和西贝尔法斯特的所有全科诊所(合并名单规模约为180,000人)以及地区医学心脏病中心。
在两年期间共收到212份申请表,192名符合条件的患者参加了运动测试。所有患者均疑似患有心肌缺血引起的疼痛,年龄≤65岁,且无运动测试禁忌症。
使用该服务的全科医生比例。运动测试阳性的比例。转诊医生对该服务的评估。
43%的全科医生转诊了患者,34次测试(18%)呈阳性。未发生并发症。转诊医生评估的缺血性心脏病的预检可能性高者有48例(25%),中等者有82例(43%),低者有62例(32%)。缺血性心脏病的高预检可能性预测阳性测试结果的敏感性为50% , 特异性为80%。全科医生决定将19名(10%)患者转诊至医院心脏病科进行进一步评估,其中包括34名运动测试阳性患者中的16名。在大多数情况下,该服务被认为是有帮助的,如果没有该服务,97%的患者会被直接转诊至医院心脏病诊所。
为疑似缺血性心脏病患者提供直接使用的运动心电图检查是安全、可行的,且对全科医生有帮助。该服务似乎减少了转诊至心脏病门诊的患者数量,并便于在社区对这些患者进行管理。