Agrawal S, Danbauchi S S, Goodfellow J, Robson S A, Reid D S
Department of Cardiology, Freeman Hospital, High Heaton, Newcastle upon Tyne NE7 7DN, UK.
Heart. 1999 Sep;82(3):378-82. doi: 10.1136/hrt.82.3.378.
To evaluate the safety, efficacy, and feasibility of the technician run open access exercise electrocardiography service at Freeman Hospital.
Questionnaire analysis of the responses of the general practitioners of randomly selected patients who used the service.
A tertiary care cardiac centre, providing an open access service to general practitioners in the community.
269 patients randomly selected from 552 who underwent open access exercise electrocardiography over a 2.5 year period.
Utilisation of service: the reasons for referral, whether the service was optimally used by the general practitioners, and its effect on their management practice; effect on number of cardiology referrals; benefit to the patients; safety, efficacy, and feasibility of a technician run service; general practitioners' assessment of the service.
147 of 178 general practitioners (82.6%) responded to the questionnaire, on 247 of 269 patients (91. 8%). General practitioners used the service for diagnosing ischaemic heart disease in 72.5% of cases, for prognostic purposes in 17.8%, or both in 5.3%. In 197 cases (79.8%), the general practitioners felt that the service had changed the way they managed their patients. The exercise test was positive in 90 patients (36.5%) and identified 38 as at high risk. The service was effective in optimising the cardiology service by reducing referrals by 47%.
The service was used by general practitioners primarily for diagnosing ischaemic heart disease and not so often for prognosis. The utilisation of the service was optimal as assessed by the high positivity rate. The service meets its primary objective of assisting general practitioners in the management of patients with suspected ischaemic heart disease, and may have helped to optimise resources by reducing the number of referrals to cardiologists. It has helped prioritize patient management and may have benefited high risk patients by facilitating rapid identification and referral. It can be run safely and effectively by trained technicians.
评估在弗里曼医院由技术人员开展的开放式运动心电图服务的安全性、有效性和可行性。
对使用该服务的随机选取患者的全科医生的回复进行问卷调查分析。
一家三级心脏护理中心,为社区全科医生提供开放式服务。
从在2.5年期间接受开放式运动心电图检查的552名患者中随机选取的269名患者。
服务利用情况:转诊原因、全科医生是否最佳利用该服务及其对他们管理实践的影响;对心脏病转诊数量的影响;对患者的益处;技术人员开展服务的安全性、有效性和可行性;全科医生对该服务的评估。
178名全科医生中的147名(82.6%)回复了问卷,涉及269名患者中的247名(91.8%)。全科医生在72.5%的病例中使用该服务诊断缺血性心脏病,17.8%用于预后目的,5.3%两者皆用。在197例(79.8%)病例中,全科医生认为该服务改变了他们管理患者的方式。运动试验在90名患者(36.5%)中呈阳性,确定38名患者为高危。该服务通过减少47%的转诊有效优化了心脏病服务。
全科医生使用该服务主要是为了诊断缺血性心脏病,而非用于预后。从高阳性率评估,该服务的利用是最佳的。该服务实现了协助全科医生管理疑似缺血性心脏病患者的主要目标,并且可能通过减少转诊至心脏病专家的数量帮助优化了资源。它有助于对患者管理进行优先排序,并且可能通过促进快速识别和转诊使高危患者受益。经过培训的技术人员可以安全有效地开展该服务。