Sulke A N, Paul V E, Taylor C J, Roberts R H, Norris A D
Guy's Hospital, London.
J R Soc Med. 1991 Oct;84(10):590-4. doi: 10.1177/014107689108401007.
An initial study of the use of open access exercise electrocardiography by general practitioners (GPs) in South East Kent showed that patient selection and interpretation of test results was frequently incorrect. After issuing guidelines, modifying the request form and instituting registrar review of all requests, significant improvements in both referral pattern, result interpretation and patient management have resulted. Forty-nine GPs requested 110 exercise tests during 1988/89. Twelve per cent were not undertaken after discussion with the referring practitioner. Eighty-four per cent of those tested would have been referred to the district general hospital cardiology outpatient department in the absence of open access exercise electrocardiography service. Six per cent of patients were referred directly for invasive investigation. Thirty-five per cent were referred to the district general hospital cardiology outpatient department, whilst 42% were spared hospital referral based on the result of the investigation. Better use of the modified service was suggested by: referral of fewer patients with non-cardiac chest pains (P = 0.002); more patients with a moderate pre-test probability of ischaemic heart disease (P less than 0.05); fewer inappropriate requests (P less than 0.01); and fewer inappropriately undertaken tests (P less than 0.001) than in the previous study. All patients with strongly positive test results were appropriately managed. Open access exercise electrocardiography in the format investigated is potentially a cost-effective and useful tool to improve diagnosis and management of heart disease by GPs.
一项对肯特郡东南部全科医生(GP)使用开放式运动心电图的初步研究表明,患者选择和检查结果解读经常出现错误。在发布指南、修改申请表并对所有申请进行注册审查后,转诊模式、结果解读和患者管理都有了显著改善。1988/89年期间,49名全科医生申请了110次运动测试。与转诊医生讨论后,12%的测试未进行。在没有开放式运动心电图服务的情况下,84%接受测试的患者会被转诊至地区综合医院心脏病门诊。6%的患者被直接转诊进行侵入性检查。35%的患者被转诊至地区综合医院心脏病门诊,而42%的患者根据检查结果无需住院转诊。以下方面表明对改进后的服务使用得更好:转诊的非心脏性胸痛患者减少(P = 0.002);缺血性心脏病预测试概率中等的患者增多(P小于0.05);不适当的申请减少(P小于0.01);与之前的研究相比,不适当进行的测试减少(P小于0.001)。所有测试结果呈强阳性的患者都得到了妥善管理。所研究形式的开放式运动心电图可能是一种具有成本效益且有用的工具,可改善全科医生对心脏病的诊断和管理。