Jackson G, Atkinson L, Oram S
Br Med J. 1975 Mar 29;1(5960):708-12. doi: 10.1136/bmj.1.5960.708.
Forty-two patients with angina pectoris have completed a randomized, double-blind trial comparing tolamolol 100 mg and 200 mg with propranolol 80 mg, practolol 100 mg, and placebo, all given three times a day. Tolamolol 200 mg thrice daily was found to be equivalent to propranolol 80 mg thrice daily in anti-anginal efficacy. Anginal attack rates and trinitrin consumption were significantly reduced by all active treatments as compared with the placebo but tolamolol and propranolol were the most effective. Tolamolol 200 mg thrice daily was most effective in reducing blood pressure, while propranolol was most effective in reducing the resting heart rate. All treatments except the placebo significantly increased the amount of exercise which could be performed before angina appeared (exercise work), while tolamolol 200 mg thrice daily significantly reduced Robinson's index when compared with all other active agents. The degree of S-T segment depression induced by exercise was significantly lessened by both tolamolol and propranolol but not by practolol or placebo. There was no difference in patient preference between tolamolol and propranolol but tolamolol at both dose levels was preferred to practolol. Both tolamolol and propranolol are potent adrenergic beta-receptor antagonists and equal in anti-anginal efficacy but tolamolol has the advantage of being cardioselective. It is superior to practolol.
42例心绞痛患者完成了一项随机双盲试验,比较了每日3次服用100毫克和200毫克托拉洛尔与80毫克普萘洛尔、100毫克普拉洛尔及安慰剂的效果。结果发现,每日3次服用200毫克托拉洛尔在抗心绞痛疗效上与每日3次服用80毫克普萘洛尔相当。与安慰剂相比,所有活性治疗药物均显著降低了心绞痛发作率和硝酸甘油消耗量,但托拉洛尔和普萘洛尔最为有效。每日3次服用200毫克托拉洛尔在降低血压方面最为有效,而普萘洛尔在降低静息心率方面最为有效。除安慰剂外,所有治疗均显著增加了心绞痛出现前可进行的运动量(运动功),而与所有其他活性药物相比,每日3次服用200毫克托拉洛尔显著降低了罗宾逊指数。运动诱发的ST段压低程度在托拉洛尔和普萘洛尔治疗后均显著减轻,但普拉洛尔或安慰剂治疗后则无此效果。患者对托拉洛尔和普萘洛尔的偏好无差异,但两种剂量水平的托拉洛尔均比普拉洛尔更受青睐。托拉洛尔和普萘洛尔均为强效肾上腺素能β受体拮抗剂,抗心绞痛疗效相当,但托拉洛尔具有心脏选择性优势,优于普拉洛尔。