Silverman D G, Brull S J
Department of Anesthesiology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut 06510.
Anesth Analg. 1993 Jun;76(6):1284-7. doi: 10.1213/00000539-199376060-00017.
We evaluated the effect of tetanic stimulation (5 s, 50 Hz, 60 mA) on the response to tetanic stimulation delivered 2 min (TET@2) and 5 min (TET@5) later in 22 anesthetized patients receiving a vecuronium infusion. Once a consistent mechanomyographic train-of-four ratio was obtained at the adductor pollicis muscle, the first (baseline) tetanic stimulus was delivered. Tetanic sequences were repeated randomly after 2- and 5-min intervals. Tetanic fade was consistent among the study periods: the tetanic fade ratio for the first second of tetanus was 0.35 during baseline tetanic stimulation, 0.32 during TET@2 (P = NS by paired t-test), and 0.33 during TET@5 (P = NS). The respective fade ratios for the entire 5-s period were 0.15, 0.15 (P = NS), and 0.14 (P = NS). In contrast, the peak tetanic height increased from 10.8 mm at baseline to 11.3 mm at TET@2 (P < 0.05), and 11.3 mm at TET@5 (P < 0.05). We conclude that, in light of the consistency exhibited by tetanic fade, the small change in twitch height is clinically insignificant.
我们评估了强直刺激(5秒,50赫兹,60毫安)对22例接受维库溴铵输注的麻醉患者在2分钟(TET@2)和5分钟(TET@5)后给予的强直刺激反应的影响。在内收拇肌获得一致的机械肌电图四个成串刺激比值后,给予第一个(基线)强直刺激。强直序列在2分钟和5分钟间隔后随机重复。强直衰减在各研究期内是一致的:基线强直刺激期间破伤风第一秒的强直衰减率为0.35,TET@2期间为0.32(配对t检验P=无显著性差异),TET@5期间为0.33(P=无显著性差异)。整个5秒期间各自的衰减率分别为0.15、0.15(P=无显著性差异)和0.14(P=无显著性差异)。相比之下,强直峰值高度从基线时的10.8毫米增加到TET@2时的11.3毫米(P<0.05),TET@5时为11.3毫米(P<0.05)。我们得出结论,鉴于强直衰减表现出的一致性,抽搐高度的微小变化在临床上无显著意义。