Nakielna E M, Cragg R, Grzybowski S
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1975 Dec;112(6):765-72. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1975.112.6.765.
There are 14,552 inactive cases of tuberculosis in British Columbia, representing 0.6 per cent of the population. The prevalence of inactive tuberculosis in 7 times higher among Indians than in the remainder of the population. Among all inactive cases, 60.5 per cent of patients had "good" chemotherapy, whereas 13.2 per cent had poor chemotherapy and 26.3 per cent had no chemotherapy. The risk of reactivation in those who received "good" chemotherapy was 2.2 cases per 1,000 persons per annum, whereas for those with poor and no chemotherapy, the risks were 7.8 and 6.7 cases per 1,000 persons per annum, respectively. One third of a sample of all inactive cases were found not to comply with the existing policy of lifelong annual examinations. Of the remaining two-thirds, one-half attended regularly and one-half, irregularly. All reactivations occurring during the 3-year period between 1971 and 1973 were reviewed. The pattern of attendance of these patients during a 3-year period immediately before the year of reactivation was similar to that of the sample of all inactive cases. Sixty per cent of reactivations occurring among "attenders" were diagnosed at such annual examinations. The bacteriologic status of reactivated disease was reviewed; 78 per cent were culture positive. Of patients who had received previous chemotherapy, 45 per cent had organisms that were resistant to one or more of the 3 primary antituberculous drugs, whereas previously untreated groups showed a much lower figure, 7.8 per cent. On the basis of the findings of this study, recommendations are made in relation to future policy of management of inactive cases of tuberculosis.
不列颠哥伦比亚省有14552例非活动性肺结核病例,占该省人口的0.6%。印第安人中非活动性肺结核的患病率是该省其他人口的7倍。在所有非活动性病例中,60.5%的患者接受了“良好”的化疗,而13.2%的患者化疗效果不佳,26.3%的患者未接受化疗。接受“良好”化疗的患者每年每1000人中复发的风险为2.2例,而化疗效果不佳和未接受化疗的患者每年每1000人中复发的风险分别为7.8例和6.7例。在所有非活动性病例样本中,有三分之一被发现未遵守现有的终身年度检查政策。在其余的三分之二中,一半患者定期就诊,一半患者不定期就诊。对1971年至1973年这3年期间发生的所有复发病例进行了回顾。这些患者在复发前3年期间的就诊模式与所有非活动性病例样本的模式相似。在“就诊者”中发生的复发病例,60%是在这种年度检查中被诊断出来的。对复发疾病的细菌学状况进行了回顾;78%的病例培养呈阳性。在之前接受过化疗的患者中,45%的患者感染的病菌对3种主要抗结核药物中的一种或多种耐药,而之前未接受治疗的患者组这一比例要低得多,为7.8%。根据本研究的结果,对未来非活动性肺结核病例的管理政策提出了建议。