Declerck P J, Moreau H, Jespersen J, Gram J, Kluft C
Center for Molecular and Vascular Biology, University of Leuven, Belgium.
Thromb Haemost. 1993 Nov 15;70(5):858-63.
In order to evaluate the comparability of data obtained with various available kits for the immunological determination of PAI-1 antigen in plasma and in order to investigate the underlying cause of observed differences, e.g. problems of specificity or of proper calibration of the provided standard, a multicenter study was organised in the framework of the Subcommittee of Fibrinolysis of the Scientific and Standardization Committee. Eight different plasma samples were distributed among 16 laboratories: a pooled normal plasma, NIBSC 87/512, PAI-1 antigen depleted plasma, PAI-1 depleted plasma supplemented with 59 ng/ml active PAI-1 and four different individual plasma samples. A considerable variation in absolute values is observed between the various kits, e.g. in pooled normal plasma a value is found ranging between 7.4 and 28 ng/ml. Harmonization of all data relative to the PAI-1-depleted plasma supplemented with an exact amount of active PAI-1 (59 ng/ml), followed by a statistical analysis using a two way analysis of variance, revealed that 6 out of 7 kits yielded values that were not significantly different with coefficients of variation around 30%. Correlations between the values obtained with these kits yielded slopes between 0.75 and 1.44 with correlation coefficients between 0.973 and 0.999. Values obtained with one kit appeared to be significantly different (even after harmonization) from the other kits (p < 0.001 to p < 0.05). Comparison of PAI-1 antigen with the PAI activity values in the analysed samples suggests that one kit may deal with a problem of a difference in reactivity between active and latent PAI-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为了评估用于免疫测定血浆中PAI-1抗原的各种现有试剂盒所获数据的可比性,并调查观察到的差异的潜在原因,例如特异性问题或所提供标准品的正确校准问题,在科学与标准化委员会纤维蛋白溶解小组委员会的框架内组织了一项多中心研究。将8种不同的血浆样本分发给16个实验室:一份混合正常血浆、NIBSC 87/512、PAI-1抗原缺失血浆、补充有59 ng/ml活性PAI-1的PAI-1缺失血浆以及4种不同的个体血浆样本。在各种试剂盒之间观察到绝对值存在相当大的差异,例如在混合正常血浆中,发现的值在7.4至28 ng/ml之间。将所有数据与补充了精确量活性PAI-1(59 ng/ml)的PAI-1缺失血浆进行校准,然后使用双向方差分析进行统计分析,结果显示7种试剂盒中有6种产生的值没有显著差异,变异系数约为30%。这些试剂盒所获值之间的相关性产生的斜率在0.75至1.44之间,相关系数在0.973至0.999之间。用一种试剂盒获得的值似乎与其他试剂盒有显著差异(即使在校准后)(p<0.001至p<0.05)。将分析样本中的PAI-1抗原与PAI活性值进行比较表明,一种试剂盒可能存在活性PAI-1和潜在PAI-1之间反应性差异的问题。(摘要截断于250字)