Joynt R L
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1994 Mar;75(3):251-8. doi: 10.1016/0003-9993(94)90024-8.
Monopolar and concentric reusable and disposable EMG needle electrodes from several manufacturers were studied at various stages of usage. Needle tips were examined and measured microscopically, and needles were tested for spontaneous noise and resistive and capacitative characteristics at four different test signal frequencies. Resistive and capacitative characteristics were found to be frequency dependent. Needle tip areas differed by as much as 10 times among the various electrodes. The amount of noise correlated most highly with resistive characteristics. Monopolar and concentric needles differed in respect to tip area, noise, and all resistive and capacitative measures. Coaxial disposable and reusable electrodes did not differ significantly and minor differences were noted in electrical characteristics between reusable and disposable monopolar needles, even from the same manufacturer. There was considerable variability among manufacturers for both needle types. In choosing an electrode, consistent tip area is probably the most important consideration to ensure repeatable quantifiable results, but minimizing needle impedance is useful to reduce noise.
对多家制造商生产的单极和同心可重复使用及一次性肌电图针电极在不同使用阶段进行了研究。对针尖进行了显微镜检查和测量,并在四种不同测试信号频率下对针进行了自发噪声、电阻和电容特性测试。发现电阻和电容特性与频率有关。不同电极之间的针尖面积相差多达10倍。噪声量与电阻特性的相关性最高。单极针和同心针在针尖面积、噪声以及所有电阻和电容测量方面存在差异。同轴一次性和可重复使用电极之间没有显著差异,即使来自同一制造商,可重复使用和一次性单极针在电气特性上也存在细微差异。两种针型在制造商之间存在相当大的变异性。在选择电极时,一致的针尖面积可能是确保可重复量化结果的最重要考虑因素,但最小化针阻抗有助于降低噪声。