Schachter L, Weingarten M A, Kahan E E
Department of Family Medicine, Kupat Holim, Beilinson Medical Center, Petah Tikva, Israel.
Arch Fam Med. 1993 Dec;2(12):1268-70. doi: 10.1001/archfami.2.12.1268.
Eighty-nine Israeli family physicians responded to a questionnaire on their experience with nonconventional therapies (NCTs) and their opinions about the scientific basis and clinical efficacy of these treatments. They were also asked whether they thought that NCTs should be incorporated into regular medical practice. Seventeen percent of the physicians had formal training in some form of NCT and 11% thought the scientific basis of these treatments was sound; however, a majority (54%) thought they may be clinically useful. Forty-two percent had referred patients for such treatments. The majority thought that NCTs should be incorporated into medical practice. Our survey suggests that many physicians are not using the tools of scientific critical appraisal in forming their views on NCTs.
89名以色列家庭医生回复了一份关于他们使用非传统疗法(NCTs)的经验以及他们对这些疗法的科学依据和临床疗效看法的调查问卷。他们还被问及是否认为非传统疗法应纳入常规医疗实践。17%的医生接受过某种形式的非传统疗法正规培训,11%的医生认为这些疗法的科学依据可靠;然而,大多数(54%)医生认为它们可能具有临床实用性。42%的医生曾将患者转诊接受此类治疗。大多数医生认为非传统疗法应纳入医疗实践。我们的调查表明,许多医生在形成对非传统疗法的看法时并未运用科学批判性评估工具。