Hals A, Jacobsen G
Det medisinske fakultet, Medisinsk Teknisk Senter, Trondheim.
Nord Med. 1994;109(3):85-8.
During the period 1986-92, a questionnaire survey was conducted among research project administrators whose study protocols were assessed by the ethical committee for biomedical research in Health region 4 (Central Norway). The questions referred to the scientists' attitudes towards medical research ethics in general, and their views on the work of the committee. They were also asked to comment on seven statements about scientific fraud and misconduct. This paper presents data on misconduct from the 119 scientists who completed the questionnaire, i.e. 70 percent of the 159 recipients. Some 40 percent claimed that scientific fraud is a problem in Norway, but 46 percent maintained that it is less so than in other countries. More than every fourth researcher (27 percent) knew of one or more cases of scientific misconduct, 42 percent stated that their knowledge was not publicly known, 18 percent felt that they had been exposed to misconduct themselves. A majority (60 percent) stated that a better system is needed to investigate claims of scientific fraud. The authors discuss these findings in relation to the personal characteristics and scientific qualifications of the researchers, and the current knowledge about the extent of scientific fraud in medicine.
在1986年至1992年期间,对研究项目管理人员进行了问卷调查,这些人员的研究方案由挪威中部卫生区4的生物医学研究伦理委员会进行评估。问题涉及科学家对医学研究伦理的总体态度,以及他们对委员会工作的看法。他们还被要求对关于科学欺诈和不当行为的七条陈述发表评论。本文展示了119名完成问卷的科学家(即159名收件人中的70%)有关不当行为的数据。约40%的人声称科学欺诈在挪威是个问题,但46%的人坚称其程度低于其他国家。超过四分之一的研究人员(27%)知晓一个或多个科学不当行为案例,42%的人表示他们所知晓的情况并未公开,18%的人觉得自己曾遭遇过不当行为。大多数人(60%)表示需要一个更好的系统来调查科学欺诈指控。作者结合研究人员的个人特征和科学资质,以及当前关于医学中科学欺诈程度的认知,对这些发现进行了讨论。