Kravitz R L, Cope D W, Bhrany V, Leake B
Division of General Internal Medicine and Health Services Research, UCLA.
J Gen Intern Med. 1994 Feb;9(2):75-81. doi: 10.1007/BF02600205.
To describe internal medicine patients' expectations for care during office visits and to examine the relationship between fulfillment of expectations for care and visit satisfaction.
Survey of patients and their physicians.
The internal medicine practice of faculty and housestaff at a large academic center in Southern California.
396 patients aged 18 to 65 years were approached in the clinic waiting room prior to their scheduled visits; 337 (85%) agreed to participate and 304 (77%) turned in completed questionnaires. Postvisit physician surveys were received in 88% of the cases.
The patients' previsit reports of the elements of care they thought necessary for their physicians to provide; the patients' and physicians' postvisit reports of the elements of care actually provided; and the patients' satisfaction with care.
Among 28 specific elements of care, seven were considered necessary by a majority of the patients (examination of the eyes/ears/nose/throat, lungs, heart, and abdomen; blood testing; prognostic counseling; and discussion of patients' own ideas about management). A higher number of elements of care were thought necessary by patients who were nonwhite and had not completed college. Up to 38% of the patients reported not receiving elements of care they had considered necessary; specific agreement between physicians and patients about care not received ranged from 63% to 100%. Not receiving certain "necessary" elements of care was associated with lower visit satisfaction.
Internal medicine patients at the center studied had specific expectations for the content of their physician visits. However, they routinely failed to receive some of the items they thought necessary. Unless patients' expectations are carefully elicited and dealt with the physician-patient relationship may be adversely affected.
描述内科患者在门诊就诊时对医疗服务的期望,并探讨医疗服务期望的满足与就诊满意度之间的关系。
对患者及其医生进行调查。
南加州一个大型学术中心内科教员和住院医师的门诊。
在诊所候诊室,对396名年龄在18至65岁的患者在其预定就诊前进行了询问;337名(85%)同意参与,304名(77%)提交了完整问卷。88%的病例收到了就诊后医生的调查问卷。
患者就诊前报告他们认为医生提供医疗服务所需的要素;患者和医生就诊后报告实际提供的医疗服务要素;以及患者对医疗服务的满意度。
在28项具体医疗服务要素中,大多数患者认为其中7项是必要的(眼睛/耳朵/鼻子/喉咙、肺部、心脏和腹部检查;血液检测;预后咨询;以及讨论患者自己关于治疗的想法)。非白人和未完成大学学业的患者认为有更多的医疗服务要素是必要的。高达38%的患者报告未得到他们认为必要的医疗服务要素;医生和患者之间关于未得到的医疗服务的具体一致率在63%至100%之间。未得到某些“必要”的医疗服务要素与较低的就诊满意度相关。
在所研究的中心,内科患者对医生就诊的内容有特定期望。然而,他们经常未能得到一些他们认为必要的项目。除非仔细了解并处理患者的期望,否则医患关系可能会受到不利影响。