Warlo H J, Doerr H W
Zentralbl Bakteriol Orig A. 1976 Apr;234(3):393-406.
Recently, also detergents have been proposed for use in the pretreatment of clinical material for cultural demonstration of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. One of such substances is the anionic detergent. Neckal BX (diisobutyl naphthaline sulphonate) which in combination with 0.5% sodium hydroxide, is capable of homogenization and decontamination of the material within 16-18 h of action. At the same time, the mycobacteria are accumulated in the sediment by precipitation in the presence of barium, calcium, and phosphate ions. The results obtained by the new method were compared with those obtained by the sulphuric acid method, in a paralles study of samples of sputum, gastric juice, and faeces and a second one of sputum samples only. By using two different formulas for reagents (Table 1), the mycobacterial isolation rate was shown to be dependent upon the concentration of the precipitant. By the following criteria, the Nekal method was superior over pretreatment with sulphuric acid: 1. The reduction of the number of contaminated was obvious in the cases of sputum and gastric juice samples and significant for sputum samples. (Tables 2-7). 2. Using Nekal BX, 31 out of 616 sputum samples were found to be positive; using sulphuric acid, their number was only 22. This difference was found to be statistically significant. The additional yield came primarily from material containing only few mycobacteria and samples which could not be assessed because of contamination present after pretreatment with sulphuric acid (Table 8). The average period which passed until reading of the cultures was approximately the same: 4.2 weeks for sulphuric acid and 4.4 weeks for Nekal (Table 9). When applying the new method, the material admits of mechanical shaking and need not be centrifuged. No strict control of the period of action is required. Taking into account these operational advantages, the Nekal method is considered particulary suitable for laboratories receiving high numbers of samples.
最近,也有人提出将洗涤剂用于临床材料的预处理,以进行结核分枝杆菌的培养鉴定。其中一种物质是阴离子洗涤剂。Neckal BX(二异丁基萘磺酸盐)与0.5%的氢氧化钠联合使用时,能够在16 - 18小时的作用时间内使材料均质化并去污。同时,在钡、钙和磷酸根离子存在的情况下,分枝杆菌会通过沉淀积聚在沉淀物中。在一项对痰液、胃液和粪便样本进行的平行研究以及另一项仅针对痰液样本的研究中,将新方法得到的结果与硫酸法得到的结果进行了比较。通过使用两种不同的试剂配方(表1),结果表明分枝杆菌的分离率取决于沉淀剂的浓度。根据以下标准,Nekal法优于硫酸预处理法:1. 在痰液和胃液样本中,污染菌数量的减少很明显,在痰液样本中则非常显著(表2 - 7)。2. 使用Nekal BX时,616份痰液样本中有31份呈阳性;使用硫酸时,阳性样本数量仅为22份。发现这种差异具有统计学意义。额外的阳性样本主要来自仅含有少量分枝杆菌的材料以及因硫酸预处理后存在污染而无法评估的样本(表8)。直到读取培养结果的平均时间大致相同:硫酸法为4.2周,Nekal法为4.4周(表9)。应用新方法时,材料可以进行机械振荡,无需离心。不需要严格控制作用时间。考虑到这些操作优势,Nekal法被认为特别适合接收大量样本的实验室。