Koch H, Gerloff W, Kalich B, Uhlemann K R
Z Erkr Atmungsorgane. 1975 Jun;143(3):212-8.
In cooperation of four laboratories the efficiency of the two detergents Präwozell N-BX (Nekal BX) and Ditalan E used for homogenization of diagnostic specimens for cultural investigations on tuberculosis was compared. The pretreatment of sputum specimens was done according to the directions given in "DAB 7 (D.L.) - DDR" [German Pharmacopocia 7(Diagnostic laboratory methods) GDR]. Percentage of positive cultures, time of growth and rate of contamination were evaluated. Comparative investigations with both methods using the same sputum specimens were performed with 2117 samples. 245 cultures were positive in all, 223 (91,0%) of them after homogenization by means of Präwozell N-BX and 205 (83,7%) pretreated with Ditalan E. Out of 161 cultures positive with both methods, the time of growth was shorter at least one week in 19 samples (12%) after using Präwozell N-BX and in 55 specimens (34%) homogenized by means of Ditalan E than in the parallel culture. The number of contaminations was 18 (0,85%) after Ditalan E pretreatment and 10 (0,47%) after Präwozell N-BX homogenization. Taking as a basis the directives concerning the cultural investigations for mycobacteria Ditalan E did not show better results than those found with Präwozell N-BX.
在四个实验室的合作下,比较了用于结核培养检查诊断标本匀浆的两种洗涤剂Präwozell N - BX(Nekal BX)和Ditalan E的效率。痰标本的预处理按照“DAB 7(D.L.) - DDR”[德意志民主共和国药典7(诊断实验室方法)]中的说明进行。评估了阳性培养物的百分比、生长时间和污染率。使用相同的痰标本对这两种方法进行了2117个样本的对比研究。总共245个培养物呈阳性,其中223个(91.0%)是在通过Präwozell N - BX匀浆后,205个(83.7%)是经Ditalan E预处理后。在两种方法均呈阳性的161个培养物中,与平行培养相比,使用Präwozell N - BX后,19个样本(12%)的生长时间至少缩短了一周,而经Ditalan E匀浆的55个标本(34%)生长时间缩短。Ditalan E预处理后的污染数为18个(0.85%),Präwozell N - BX匀浆后的污染数为10个(0.47%)。以关于分枝杆菌培养检查的指令为依据,Ditalan E并未显示出比Präwozell N - BX更好的结果。