A randomized feasibility study evaluating the effect of radiotherapy alone or combined with 5-fluorouracil in the treatment of locally recurrent or inoperable colorectal carcinoma.

The effect of radiotherapy alone or given simultaneously with 5-FU in the treatment of locally recurrent or inoperable colorectal carcinoma was investigated in a randomized feasibility trial. Twenty-nine patients were randomized to radiotherapy alone (50 Gy/5 weeks + 10-20 Gy boost), and 30 patients to the same radiotherapy with weekly 5-FU (600 mg/m2) given before treatment every Monday during the first 5 weeks. The two groups were comparable with regard to age, sex, previous treatment, symptoms, tumour size and performance status. Treatment compliance to radiotherapy was the same in both groups with 87% receiving at least 50 Gy. Drug treatment was completed in 18/30 patients. Overall the treatment resulted in a significant palliative effect in 73% of evaluable patients with a median duration of 26 months, and objective response in 32% (8 CR, 11 PR), with a median duration of 18 months. The 3-year actuarial survival rate was 9% (median 12 months). Only patients who achieved CR became long-time survivors (63% 3-year actuarial survival). Similarly, performance status had a strong association with survival. Multivariate analysis showed complete response and high performance status to be the only parameters having prognostic influence on survival. Addition of 5-FU did neither influence the objective or symptomatic response, nor the development of distant metastases. However, addition of the drug resulted in an apparent increase in the frequency of severe acute radiation complications (33% vs. 13% after irradiation alone).