SippensGroenewegen A, Spekhorst H, van Hemel N M, Kingma J H, Hauer R N, de Bakker J M, Grimbergen C A, Janse M J, Dunning A J
Department of Clinical and Experimental Cardiology, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Circulation. 1993 Nov;88(5 Pt 1):2290-306. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.88.5.2290.
The purpose of this study was to assess the value of body surface mapping and the standard 12-lead ECG in localizing the site of origin of postinfarction ventricular tachycardia (VT) during endocardial pace mapping of the left ventricle.
Simultaneous recordings of 62-lead body surface QRS integral maps and scalar 12-lead ECG tracings were obtained in 16 patients with prior myocardial infarction during a total of 26 distinct VT configurations and during subsequent left ventricular catheter pace mapping at 9 to 24 different endocardial sites. Anatomic pacing site locations were computed by means of a biplane cineradiographic method and plotted on a polar projection of the left ventricle. The QRS integral map and the QRS complexes of the 12 standard leads of each VT morphology obtained in a particular patient were compared independently with the different paced QRS integral maps and paced QRS complexes of the 12-lead ECG generated in that same patient. The stimulus site locations of the best matching paced QRS integral map and paced QRS complexes of the 12-lead ECG were indicated on the polar projection and subsequently compared with the endocardial location of the corresponding site of VT origin identified during intraoperative (surgical ablation) or catheter activation sequence mapping (catheter ablation). The localization resolution of pace mapping was established separately for each electrocardiographic technique by computing the size of endocardial areas with similar morphological features of the QRS complex. Pace mapping advocated with body surface mapping or the 12-lead ECG enabled adequate reproduction of the VT QRS morphology in 24 of 26 VTs (92%) and 25 of 26 VTs (96%), respectively. Activation sequence mapping identified the site of origin in 12 of 26 previously observed VT configurations (46%). Ten and 11 VTs were localized by activation sequence mapping and pace mapping combined with body surface mapping or the 12-lead ECG, respectively. Pace mapping applied with body surface mapping identified the site of origin correctly (distance < or = 2 cm) in 8 of 10 compared VTs (80%); an adjacent site (distance between 2 and 4 cm) or a disparate site (distance > or = 4 cm) was identified in the remaining 2 of 10 VTs (20%). Pace mapping used with the 12-lead ECG localized the site of origin correctly in 2 of 11 VTs (18%); the site of origin was identified correctly next to an additional adjacent site in 5 of 11 VTs (55%); and an adjacent site or a disparate site was found in 1 of 11 VTs (9%) and 2 of 11 VTs (18%), respectively. The difference in localization accuracy of both electrocardiographic techniques was statistically significant (P = .02). The mean size of endocardial areas where a comparable QRS morphology was obtained during pace mapping was 6.0 +/- 4.5 cm2 with the application of body surface mapping and 15.1 +/- 12.0 cm2 with the use of the 12-lead ECG.
These results demonstrate that application of the 62-lead instead of the 12-lead ECG during endocardial pace mapping enhances the localization resolution of this mapping technique and enables more precise identification of the site of arrhythmogenesis in the majority of compared postinfarction VT episodes.
本研究旨在评估在左心室内膜起搏标测过程中,体表标测和标准12导联心电图在确定心肌梗死后室性心动过速(VT)起源部位方面的价值。
在16例既往有心肌梗死的患者中,共记录了26种不同的VT形态,以及随后在9至24个不同心内膜部位进行左心室导管起搏标测时的62导联体表QRS积分图和标量12导联心电图描记。通过双平面电影造影法计算解剖起搏部位,并绘制在左心室的极坐标投影图上。将特定患者获得的每种VT形态的QRS积分图和12个标准导联的QRS波群,分别与该患者产生的不同起搏QRS积分图和12导联心电图的起搏QRS波群进行独立比较。在极坐标投影图上标记出与起搏QRS积分图和12导联心电图的起搏QRS波群最佳匹配的刺激部位,随后与术中(手术消融)或导管激动序列标测(导管消融)确定的相应VT起源部位的心内膜位置进行比较。通过计算具有相似QRS波群形态特征的心内膜区域大小,分别为每种心电图技术确定起搏标测的定位分辨率。采用体表标测或12导联心电图进行的起搏标测,分别在26个VT中的24个(92%)和26个VT中的25个(96%)中能够充分再现VT的QRS形态。激动序列标测在26个先前观察到的VT形态中的12个(46%)中确定了起源部位。分别有10个和11个VT通过激动序列标测以及结合体表标测或12导联心电图的起搏标测得以定位。采用体表标测进行的起搏标测,在10个比较的VT中有8个(80%)正确确定了起源部位(距离≤2 cm);其余10个VT中的2个(20%)确定为相邻部位(距离在2至4 cm之间)或不同部位(距离≥4 cm)。采用12导联心电图进行的起搏标测,在11个VT中有2个(18%)正确定位了起源部位;在11个VT中有5个(55%)在另一个相邻部位旁边正确确定了起源部位;在11个VT中有1个(9%)和2个(18%)分别确定为相邻部位或不同部位。两种心电图技术在定位准确性上的差异具有统计学意义(P = 0.02)。在应用体表标测时,起搏标测过程中获得可比QRS形态的心内膜区域平均大小为6.0±4.5 cm²;在使用12导联心电图时为15.1±12.0 cm²。
这些结果表明,在心内膜起搏标测过程中应用62导联而非12导联心电图,可提高该标测技术的定位分辨率,并能在大多数比较的心肌梗死后VT发作中更精确地识别心律失常的起源部位。