Romans S E, Walton V A, McNoe B, Herbison G P, Mullen P E
Br J Psychiatry. 1993 Dec;163:733-8. doi: 10.1192/bjp.163.6.733.
Women who showed new psychiatric morbidity after a 30-month follow-up of a random community sample of New Zealand women were compared with those who were free of psychiatric disorder at follow-up. There were 25 new cases among the 215 women who were originally not psychiatric cases and who were re-interviewed. Using the weighted back population data to obtain prevalence figures for the general population, 6.9% became new cases over the two and a half years. Those who developed psychiatric disorder initially showed more psychiatric symptoms at a subdiagnostic level. Baseline factors that preceded the onset of psychiatric disorder were being separated or divorced, coming from a large family, having poor social networks, living alone, having few social role responsibilities such as paid employment or motherhood, and having poor physical health. An additional cross-sectional association at follow-up was poor financial security. Good social networks were closely linked with the number of a woman's social roles and appeared to protect her against the onset of psychiatric disorder. Consistent with the initial cross-sectional study, the follow-up data provide no support for marriage and child-care being risk factors for female psychiatric disorder. However, in New Zealand, these factors indicate social integration and are associated with superior mental health.
对新西兰女性的随机社区样本进行30个月随访后,出现新发精神疾病的女性与随访时无精神障碍的女性进行了比较。在最初无精神疾病且接受重新访谈的215名女性中,有25例新发病例。利用加权回溯人口数据得出普通人群的患病率,两年半内6.9%的人成为新病例。最初出现精神障碍的人在亚诊断水平上最初表现出更多的精神症状。精神障碍发病前的基线因素包括分居或离婚、来自大家庭、社交网络差、独居、几乎没有诸如带薪工作或母亲身份等社会角色责任以及身体健康状况差。随访时的另一个横断面关联是经济保障差。良好的社交网络与女性社会角色的数量密切相关,似乎能保护她免受精神障碍的发作。与最初的横断面研究一致,随访数据不支持婚姻和育儿是女性精神障碍的危险因素这一观点。然而,在新西兰,这些因素表明社会融合,并与更好的心理健康相关。