Gasparini M D, Balzarini L, Castellani M R, Tesoro Tess J D, Maffioli L S, Petrillo R, Ceglia E, Musumeci R, Buraggi G L
Department of Nuclear Medicine, National Cancer Institute, Milan, Italy.
Cancer. 1993 Jul 15;72(2):577-82. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19930715)72:2<577::aid-cncr2820720240>3.0.co;2-1.
A residual mediastinal mass after treatment represents a common diagnostic problem in the management of patients with Hodgkin lymphoma (HD). Conventional diagnostic radiology, computed tomography (CT), or ultrasonography (US) do not adequately reflect changes as fibrosis or necrosis. Gallium-67 (67Ga) imaging has been proven to be useful for the evaluation of HD in the mediastinum. The authors compared the ability of gallium scan and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate the mediastinal disease in the follow-up of patients with HD.
Thirty-four patients previously treated for HD were investigated with gallium scan, MRI, and all the other investigations to evaluate the mediastinal region. Sixteen patients were in restaging after treatment, and 18 were investigated for suspected radiologic recurrence in the mediastinum (follow-up, 9-75 months). The results of gallium scan and MRI were matched with clinical findings during the follow-up.
A sensitivity of 85.7% for 67Ga and 92.8% for MRI was found, while the specificity was 100% for the scan and 80.6% for MRI. The predictive positive value that resulted was 100% for 67Ga and 68.4% for MRI.
Both examinations were accurate in assessing the activity of residual masses in the mediastinum after treatment. 67Ga showed a lower sensitivity in comparison with MRI, but 67Ga frequently overestimates the presence of pathologic tissue. The authors acknowledge the complementary role of these two tests, but if only one of these examinations can be performed for logistic or economic reasons, then gallium scan represents the single most adequate diagnostic procedure.
治疗后残留的纵隔肿块是霍奇金淋巴瘤(HD)患者管理中常见的诊断问题。传统的诊断性放射学、计算机断层扫描(CT)或超声检查(US)不能充分反映纤维化或坏死等变化。镓-67(67Ga)显像已被证明对评估纵隔HD有用。作者比较了镓扫描和磁共振成像(MRI)在HD患者随访中评估纵隔疾病的能力。
对34例先前接受过HD治疗的患者进行了镓扫描、MRI及所有其他评估纵隔区域的检查。16例患者在治疗后进行再分期,18例因怀疑纵隔放射学复发接受检查(随访9 - 75个月)。在随访期间,将镓扫描和MRI的结果与临床发现进行匹配。
67Ga的敏感性为85.7%,MRI的敏感性为92.8%,而扫描的特异性为100%,MRI的特异性为80.6%。由此得出的预测阳性值,67Ga为100%,MRI为68.4%。
两种检查在评估治疗后纵隔残留肿块的活性方面均准确。与MRI相比,67Ga的敏感性较低,但67Ga经常高估病理组织的存在。作者承认这两种检查的互补作用,但如果由于后勤或经济原因只能进行其中一项检查,那么镓扫描是最充分的单一诊断程序。