Genuis S J, Chang W C, Genuis S K
University of Alberta, Edmonton.
CMAJ. 1993 Jul 15;149(2):153-61.
To determine public attitudes toward the use and possible limitations of assisted reproductive technology (ART).
Mail survey based on telephone numbers selected at random by computer.
Edmonton.
A total of 602 Edmonton residents aged 16 years or more (57% of eligible subjects) reached by telephone agreed to participate. Completed questionnaires were received from 455 subjects (76%).
Attitudes toward egg donation, sperm donation, selective fetal reduction, embryo freezing and experimentation, and surrogacy, as determined through responses to five cases. Comments and demographic data were also solicited.
Overall, 66% and 63% respectively of the respondents would donate an egg or sperm to a sibling; the corresponding rates for donation to a stranger were 41% and 44%. Selective fetal reduction was supported by 47% of the respondents, although only 24% would support fetal reduction to eliminate fetuses of an undesired sex. Most (64%) thought that live embryo freezing should be permitted by law. A total of 74% agreed with surrogacy if done for medical reasons, but 85% opposed its use for reasons of convenience. Overall, 72% of the respondents thought that ART should be regulated. A total of 58% felt that physicians should be primarily responsible for determining the allowable limits of this technology, and 38% felt that the public should be primarily responsible. Only 21% agreed with public funding of ART. Religious affiliation strongly influenced attitudes toward ART.
Public support for ART varies depending on the circumstances of its use. Education is needed to make the general community aware of the various aspects of ART. The results of this survey should help physicians and governing bodies make informed decisions about the future directions of ART in Canada.
确定公众对辅助生殖技术(ART)的使用及其可能存在的局限性的态度。
基于计算机随机选取电话号码进行的邮寄调查。
埃德蒙顿。
通过电话联系到的602名年龄在16岁及以上的埃德蒙顿居民(占符合条件受试者的57%)同意参与。455名受试者(76%)返回了完整问卷。
通过对五个案例的回答确定对卵子捐赠、精子捐赠、选择性减胎、胚胎冷冻与实验以及代孕的态度。还征集了意见和人口统计学数据。
总体而言,分别有66%和63%的受访者愿意向兄弟姐妹捐赠卵子或精子;向陌生人捐赠的相应比例为41%和44%。47%的受访者支持选择性减胎,不过只有24%的人会支持为了消除性别不符合意愿的胎儿而进行减胎。大多数人(64%)认为法律应允许冷冻活体胚胎。共有74%的人同意出于医疗原因进行代孕,但85%的人反对因便利原因使用代孕。总体而言,72%的受访者认为ART应受到监管。共有58%的人认为医生应主要负责确定该技术的允许范围,38%的人认为应由公众主要负责。只有21%的人同意为ART提供公共资金。宗教信仰强烈影响对ART的态度。
公众对ART的支持因使用情况而异。需要开展教育以使普通民众了解ART的各个方面。本次调查结果应有助于医生和管理机构就加拿大ART的未来发展方向做出明智决策。