Mashberg A, Boffetta P, Winkelman R, Garfinkel L
Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, East Orange, New Jersey.
Cancer. 1993 Aug 15;72(4):1369-75. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19930815)72:4<1369::aid-cncr2820720436>3.0.co;2-l.
Independent carcinogenic effects of alcohol drinking and tobacco smoking as well as their interaction can be usefully studied in a population of heavy drinkers and smokers.
A hospital-based case-control study was conducted during 1972 to 1983 in a large Veterans hospital in East Orange, New Jersey. A total of 359 oral cavity-oropharynx cancer cases and 2280 controls were interviewed according to tobacco smoking, use of smokeless tobacco, alcoholic beverage, coffee and tea drinking, race, family origin, religion, and occupation as bartender.
Odds ratio of oral cancer increased up to the level of 35 cigarettes per day and 21 whiskey equivalents per day: no further increase was found for higher level of exposure to either factor. A protective effect of quitting smoking was found, but the number of former smokers was small. No difference occurred in oral cancer risk according to type of alcoholic beverage drunk. An interaction effect compatible with a multiplicative model was found between the two exposures. Blacks were at lower risk than whites, and, in the latter group, individuals of Italian origin were at lower risk than individuals from northern or central European countries.
Alcohol drinking and tobacco smoking were responsible for the majority of oral cancer cases in this population of US Veterans.
饮酒和吸烟的独立致癌作用及其相互作用,在大量酗酒者和吸烟者群体中能够得到有效的研究。
1972年至1983年期间,在新泽西州东奥兰治的一家大型退伍军人医院开展了一项基于医院的病例对照研究。根据吸烟情况、无烟烟草使用情况、酒精饮料、咖啡和茶的饮用情况、种族、家庭出身、宗教以及是否从事酒保职业,对总共359例口腔-口咽癌病例和2280名对照进行了访谈。
口腔癌的比值比在每天吸烟达35支和每天饮用相当于21杯威士忌的酒精饮料时上升,对于这两种因素更高水平的暴露未发现进一步上升。发现戒烟有保护作用,但既往吸烟者数量较少。根据饮用酒精饮料的类型,口腔癌风险未出现差异。在两种暴露之间发现了与相乘模型相符的相互作用效应。黑人的风险低于白人,在白人组中,意大利裔个体的风险低于来自北欧或中欧国家的个体。
在美国退伍军人这一群体中,饮酒和吸烟是大多数口腔癌病例的病因。