Bartlett J C, Searcy J
Program in Human Development and Communication Sciences, University of Texas, Dallas.
Cogn Psychol. 1993 Jul;25(3):281-316. doi: 10.1006/cogp.1993.1007.
If the mouth and eyes of a face are inverted, the altered construction appears grotesque when upright, but not when upside-down. Three studies of this "Thatcher illusion" employed faces that were grotesque when upright because: (a) their eyes and mouths had been inverted ("Thatcherized" faces), (b) their eyes and mouths had been moved (spatially distorted faces), or (c) they had grotesque posed expressions. Inversion reduced the apparent grotesqueness of both Thatcherized and spatially distorted faces, but not grotesque-expression faces. Moreover, Thatcherized and distorted faces, although not grotesque-expression faces, were judged as more similar to normal, smiling faces when face-pairs were inverted than when they were upright. Similarity ratings to inverted face-pairs were correlated with latencies of response to these pairs in a task that encouraged attention to components (e.g., mouths, eyes) rather than wholistic properties. Similarity ratings to upright face-pairs showed no such correlation, and this and other findings suggested that although similarity ratings to upright faces are based on wholistic information, similarity ratings to inverted faces are based largely on components. The Thatcher illusion reflects a disruption of encoding of wholistic information when faces are inverted.
如果一张脸的嘴巴和眼睛被颠倒,那么这种改变后的结构在正立时看起来很怪异,但倒过来时却并非如此。关于这种“撒切尔错觉”的三项研究使用了在正立时很怪异的脸,原因如下:(a) 它们的眼睛和嘴巴被颠倒了(“撒切尔化”的脸),(b) 它们的眼睛和嘴巴被移动了(空间扭曲的脸),或者 (c) 它们有怪异的表情姿势。颠倒减少了撒切尔化脸和空间扭曲脸的明显怪异程度,但对有怪异表情的脸却没有效果。此外,撒切尔化的脸和扭曲的脸,虽然不是有怪异表情的脸,但在脸对颠倒时比正立时被判断为与正常的笑脸更相似。在一项鼓励关注面部组成部分(如嘴巴、眼睛)而非整体特征的任务中,对颠倒脸对的相似度评分与对这些脸对的反应潜伏期相关。对正立脸对的相似度评分则没有这种相关性,这一发现以及其他结果表明,虽然对正立脸的相似度评分基于整体信息,但对颠倒脸的相似度评分很大程度上基于组成部分。撒切尔错觉反映了脸颠倒时整体信息编码的破坏。