Silver H, David D, Kaplan M, Hadjez J, Tubi N, Darnel A, Calev A, Lerer B
Flugelman (Marza) Psychiatric Hospital, Doar Na Ashrat, Israel.
Schizophr Res. 1993 Jun;10(1):67-75. doi: 10.1016/0920-9964(93)90078-w.
This study examines the factor structure of persistent schizophrenic symptoms and compares factors derived from different rating scales. Forty stable chronic schizophrenic patients were assessed for positive and negative symptoms. In factor analysis, 3 factors could be detected: a negative factor which correlated with low drug dose and increased involuntary movements, a thought disturbance/paranoid factor which correlated negatively with extrapyramidal side effects and a delusion/hallucination factor which correlated negatively with involuntary movements. These findings support the existence of a negative factor but only partly the trichotomous division of schizophrenic symptoms. Positive symptom organisation is heterogeneous but thought disorder marks one clear dimension and non-paranoid delusions and hallucinations may mark another. The type of scale used has very significant effects on the findings.
本研究考察了持续性精神分裂症症状的因素结构,并比较了不同评定量表得出的因素。对40例病情稳定的慢性精神分裂症患者的阳性和阴性症状进行了评估。在因素分析中,可以检测到3个因素:一个与低药物剂量和不自主运动增加相关的阴性因素,一个与锥体外系副作用呈负相关的思维障碍/偏执因素,以及一个与不自主运动呈负相关的妄想/幻觉因素。这些发现支持了阴性因素的存在,但仅部分支持精神分裂症症状的三分法。阳性症状的组织是异质性的,但思维障碍标志着一个明确的维度,而非偏执性妄想和幻觉可能标志着另一个维度。所使用的量表类型对研究结果有非常显著的影响。